Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: The Bernie Sanders race argument is a cheap shot. [View all]freshwest
(53,661 posts)153. I'm not sure where I was going there, I'm tired. And that OP was weird. The pics
seemed to have nothing to do with the article, which also didn't make sense.
Also, I am tired of listening to white people talking about black people like they know better.
I think I meant to say 'argument' instead of 'agreement' last night but I was tired. I try to grasp what each poster is really saying and I want there to be peace amongst DUers.
I've seen too many times in my life and I'm in my sixties, where middle class black families, professionals, union folks, etc. were nudged out of property, jobs, etc. by blatant theft and work by government and private forces by racism... Yes, it was economics in the end. But racism is what allowed it to happen and was a direct factor taken into account on who was to be spared and who was going to be shafted. We can have a circular argument on this here.
Racism is an underlying cancer that I don't see as having gone away, in fact the institutionalized violence against black men and women appears to be worse now because it's in the open. As Americans, we should have learned - but some people are running from it. Others are playing as if they don't know. Others say it doesn't exist or doesn't matter. It's still seen as business as usual and it never should have been.
And I have stated before Sanders announced his run that I will vote for him in the primary as my preferred choice. I get tired of terms like Hillbot just as I got tired of Obamabot. But around here, some people are acting like it's an article of faith like being Protestant or Catholic, and I don't play that game.
I accept no kudos as someone who jumped into my Bernie video thread to trash HRC when I said I was for Bernie. Suddenly he thought I was a member of he choir. It's this kind of thing is why I won't post in some threads or groups as if I need to pass a religious test. It's a big turn off. And I am sure that neither HRC or Bernie act anything like people at DU do - or they would not be worth a vote. If I wanted to vote for someone that acts as some do here, I'd be a bagger. it's low down and a turn off.
I post in the HRC group and found them to be friendly, but she was never my first choice. They know and accept that just as they know I have a foot in both sides. I don't have to pick one over the other, or love one and hate the other. We have not got a nominee yet.
The thought of a Bush, Cruz, Walker, etc. in the White House would be a victory for the billionaire class Bernie's running against. He's not running against one person, and this personality routine is a huge turnoff. Those who say they will not vote at all if HRC gets the nod, are not doing it to follow Bernie's lead, he knows the GOP is fully owned by the Koch brothers, etc. He sees the real enemy, and it is not HRC.
I am missing some good positive news because I am sick of pile on threads and use Ignore. Life is too short to argue with those who are negative all the time from any side of these arguments. They are not going to change a thing.
I've already talked privately with the OP author about being more clear, etc. I'm not sure what the post was about. I didn't see the pics at first, my browser didn't show them so I didn't get the entire incendiary effect that you must have seen.
There have been a number of people turned off by Bernie's supporters. Because of the attack mode. I put such people on Ignore. I do the same and or correct HRC supporters if I see them doing it. They don't answer me and if they keep it up, I put them on Ignore. I don't come here for this level of bull.
To the economics point, I believe that black people should be a legally protected minority since they were a legally abused minority since before the nation was founded. That the poverty is generational is no news to me, I'm not sure why it would be to anyone, and I've spoken of it in the past on this board.
But if the post you reacted to so strongly was wrong (I thought it was so utterly confusing I didn't know if it was wrong or right) it was also wrong for you to post an OP intimating that DUers were calling Bernie racist. No one in their right mind would say that.
I don't believe it's true of HRC, either, by the way. You don't get as far as they have with some provincial, petty bullcrap like that motivating one.
My favorite candidate would have been Van Jones. He'll never be given a chance and has moved on. Until then, Bernie is my man... I've always said that but don't want to be in the Bernie crowd here as some of the crowd is more 'anti-HRC' than pro-Bernie. Bernie is not, either, the ultra liberal savior some seem determined to wave in everyone's face.
For every vote that people like to pull out that HRC did wrong, I can pull out one that the same group would not like done by Bernie. It doesn't prove that he is unprincipled, an opportunist, or whatever perjoratives people want to apply to the person they don't like. He is pragmatic and about Jobs first. No matter what the jobs are, so long as they keep up a standard of living that people can feel free with
And it's the person some don't like, what I often see are people pulling up things to bolster their disdain. They are filtering and it says more about them than the person they are attacking.
Black people will be supporting whoever they choose, as they are not, any more than any other group a monolith. Nor are they a pawn to be used by white politicans to win elections and then discarded. The disaffection of black voters against political parties is real and it is justified.
I'll be voting for the Democrat no matter who it is, BTW. I can't afford to pretend I don't know what I know, about how the GOP intends to treat us.
Also, I am tired of listening to white people talking about black people like they know better.
I think I meant to say 'argument' instead of 'agreement' last night but I was tired. I try to grasp what each poster is really saying and I want there to be peace amongst DUers.
I've seen too many times in my life and I'm in my sixties, where middle class black families, professionals, union folks, etc. were nudged out of property, jobs, etc. by blatant theft and work by government and private forces by racism... Yes, it was economics in the end. But racism is what allowed it to happen and was a direct factor taken into account on who was to be spared and who was going to be shafted. We can have a circular argument on this here.
Racism is an underlying cancer that I don't see as having gone away, in fact the institutionalized violence against black men and women appears to be worse now because it's in the open. As Americans, we should have learned - but some people are running from it. Others are playing as if they don't know. Others say it doesn't exist or doesn't matter. It's still seen as business as usual and it never should have been.
And I have stated before Sanders announced his run that I will vote for him in the primary as my preferred choice. I get tired of terms like Hillbot just as I got tired of Obamabot. But around here, some people are acting like it's an article of faith like being Protestant or Catholic, and I don't play that game.
I accept no kudos as someone who jumped into my Bernie video thread to trash HRC when I said I was for Bernie. Suddenly he thought I was a member of he choir. It's this kind of thing is why I won't post in some threads or groups as if I need to pass a religious test. It's a big turn off. And I am sure that neither HRC or Bernie act anything like people at DU do - or they would not be worth a vote. If I wanted to vote for someone that acts as some do here, I'd be a bagger. it's low down and a turn off.
I post in the HRC group and found them to be friendly, but she was never my first choice. They know and accept that just as they know I have a foot in both sides. I don't have to pick one over the other, or love one and hate the other. We have not got a nominee yet.
The thought of a Bush, Cruz, Walker, etc. in the White House would be a victory for the billionaire class Bernie's running against. He's not running against one person, and this personality routine is a huge turnoff. Those who say they will not vote at all if HRC gets the nod, are not doing it to follow Bernie's lead, he knows the GOP is fully owned by the Koch brothers, etc. He sees the real enemy, and it is not HRC.
I am missing some good positive news because I am sick of pile on threads and use Ignore. Life is too short to argue with those who are negative all the time from any side of these arguments. They are not going to change a thing.
I've already talked privately with the OP author about being more clear, etc. I'm not sure what the post was about. I didn't see the pics at first, my browser didn't show them so I didn't get the entire incendiary effect that you must have seen.
There have been a number of people turned off by Bernie's supporters. Because of the attack mode. I put such people on Ignore. I do the same and or correct HRC supporters if I see them doing it. They don't answer me and if they keep it up, I put them on Ignore. I don't come here for this level of bull.
To the economics point, I believe that black people should be a legally protected minority since they were a legally abused minority since before the nation was founded. That the poverty is generational is no news to me, I'm not sure why it would be to anyone, and I've spoken of it in the past on this board.
But if the post you reacted to so strongly was wrong (I thought it was so utterly confusing I didn't know if it was wrong or right) it was also wrong for you to post an OP intimating that DUers were calling Bernie racist. No one in their right mind would say that.
I don't believe it's true of HRC, either, by the way. You don't get as far as they have with some provincial, petty bullcrap like that motivating one.
My favorite candidate would have been Van Jones. He'll never be given a chance and has moved on. Until then, Bernie is my man... I've always said that but don't want to be in the Bernie crowd here as some of the crowd is more 'anti-HRC' than pro-Bernie. Bernie is not, either, the ultra liberal savior some seem determined to wave in everyone's face.
For every vote that people like to pull out that HRC did wrong, I can pull out one that the same group would not like done by Bernie. It doesn't prove that he is unprincipled, an opportunist, or whatever perjoratives people want to apply to the person they don't like. He is pragmatic and about Jobs first. No matter what the jobs are, so long as they keep up a standard of living that people can feel free with
And it's the person some don't like, what I often see are people pulling up things to bolster their disdain. They are filtering and it says more about them than the person they are attacking.
Black people will be supporting whoever they choose, as they are not, any more than any other group a monolith. Nor are they a pawn to be used by white politicans to win elections and then discarded. The disaffection of black voters against political parties is real and it is justified.
I'll be voting for the Democrat no matter who it is, BTW. I can't afford to pretend I don't know what I know, about how the GOP intends to treat us.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
184 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Please tell me whether you get on DUers that support Hillary Clinton that whine when they feel
davidpdx
May 2015
#138
"claim that Bernie is somehow not in favor of total racial equality." bullshit
seabeyond
May 2015
#50
That is exactly what the poster implied. The claim is that Bernie has not reached out
bettyellen
May 2015
#52
it was a black blogger that had nothing to do with du, AND i personally think
seabeyond
May 2015
#66
no. and still you said duers and ME were calling sanders a racist. and no one was. no.
seabeyond
May 2015
#97
Posted by someone in the 'Not Good Enough, Bernie' OP, it's this woman's blog from May 27
appalachiablue
May 2015
#139
So you know this is the blog writer of 'Not good enough, Bernie', Nancy Letourneau
appalachiablue
May 2015
#143
Sorry to know that, but now I recall hearing of the strange blogsite once or twice.
appalachiablue
May 2015
#173
he started it last night with his OP. so everyone gets to play in it today. nt
seabeyond
May 2015
#69
you did NOT start an OP late last night accusing people of saying, sanders is a racist?
seabeyond
May 2015
#84
Being warned that they're just getting started & you'll never survive till the primaries
appalachiablue
May 2015
#156
Nope- you're saying quite clearly that the issue is a ginned up one quite clearly.
bettyellen
May 2015
#65
I just saw this op - and responded to another one on his demographics in VT
JustAnotherGen
May 2015
#35
Exactly- and the reaction here claiming there were accusations of racism is BS
bettyellen
May 2015
#14
It is one incendiary photo to illustrate an incendiary issue - one that people fear will be ignored.
bettyellen
May 2015
#44
I see your agreement. But if is all economics, why was black skin an excuse for slavery for life?
freshwest
May 2015
#113
I'm not sure where I was going there, I'm tired. And that OP was weird. The pics
freshwest
May 2015
#153
"Also, I am tired of listening to white people talking about black people like they know better."
BrotherIvan
May 2015
#178
Europeans did not enslave other Europeans for life, esp. in western Europe per se like they
appalachiablue
May 2015
#163
Thanks for the primer, I knew most of that already. My question was rhetorical and specific. n/t
freshwest
May 2015
#167
That's great, I just elaborated on what you brought up, but knew already- why and how whites
appalachiablue
May 2015
#172
Note, 'optics' has been used at least 7 times in 2 different posts I've read in the last 30 minutes.
appalachiablue
May 2015
#116
I told poster the OP should have been formatted differently to not give a misconception. But I agree
freshwest
May 2015
#112
Great post- but I really didn't see anyone say anything more than his lack of addressing
bettyellen
May 2015
#157
i have concluded this morning, this fabricated, sanders is a racist, is simple another way for pro
seabeyond
May 2015
#161
how does one reconcile insisting on exclusive, when gaining votes is a must for a win, is the right
seabeyond
May 2015
#169
Agreed and I'm not interested in seeing white people get into a pissing contest on who's a racist.
freshwest
May 2015
#110
Bernie has been stressing 8 universal subjects. Implicit in several of them is the issue of race
RufusTFirefly
May 2015
#45
There should be no more "implicit", come out with the out front issues of the voting block and addre
uponit7771
May 2015
#126
Me being 21 times more likely to be shot by the police has NOTHING to do with income, it's my skin
uponit7771
May 2015
#127
this is the bluntly obvious reality. i have said this repeatedly, no impact. i do not get it. same
seabeyond
May 2015
#150
The media has homganized the issue into "the cops wont murder your kids if your rich" and made the
uponit7771
May 2015
#152
Economic inequality is directly linked to race issues. If this country were to
Exilednight
May 2015
#74
a person can be economically comfortable, still experience social injustice. no, not fact.
seabeyond
May 2015
#83
Go back and read what I posted and stop trying to put words in my mouth. n/t
Exilednight
May 2015
#85
no. just cause you lost the argument, does not mean there is wiggle room out. you CLAIMED
seabeyond
May 2015
#92
There is no argument. There is only the truth, and I stayed the truth. Have the day you deserve.
Exilednight
May 2015
#106
Me being 21 times more likely to be shot by the police has NOTHING to do with income, it's my skin
uponit7771
May 2015
#128
Not true. If you lived in a middle-class neighborhood, your chances would drastically
Exilednight
May 2015
#135
The guy shot in the back in the Walmart and the guy shot in the back in Utah lived in middle class
uponit7771
May 2015
#145
You're not going to back up what you said with anything empirical doesn't mean I'm full of anything
uponit7771
May 2015
#158
Interesting statement about 'priorities' as economic and racial inequality are like conjoined twins
azurnoir
May 2015
#78
as long as there is a gap in income based on race my point stands the same would be true of gender
azurnoir
May 2015
#102
I'm STILL 21 more times likely to get shot by the police has NOTHING to do with money... that's the
uponit7771
May 2015
#125
He did attend the black lives matter parade in NYC, IIRC. Willing to be corrected. n/t
freshwest
May 2015
#109
all it is, is a demographic issue. i say we relax and see where he goes. it is just the start. nt
seabeyond
May 2015
#11
Those who are trying to paint Bernie as a racist are most likely paid corporatist trolls.
Zorra
May 2015
#18
"trying to paint Bernie as a racist " that would be NO ONE. those trying to paint duers
seabeyond
May 2015
#19
Thanks. Every genuine poster here knows the obvious: neither Bernie nor Hillary have
Zorra
May 2015
#24
No, not all of us. Some of us have not forgotten the racism in Hillary's 2008 campaign.
ieoeja
May 2015
#56
Yes they are. Sexist, too. Same old, same old accusations from a certain group of DUers.
merrily
May 2015
#132
You are entitled to your opinion. I can't think of any other reason why any sincere person would
Zorra
May 2015
#37
Straw man. I haven't seen DU'ers painted Sanders as a racist. Just inept at dealing with race
KittyWampus
May 2015
#31
Best to stop piling it on, the wagon is already overloaded with race baiting horseshit. nt
Zorra
May 2015
#40
Please link to these claims of Sanders being racist or stop putting horrid words in people's
bettyellen
May 2015
#47
So? Governor Clinton had African Americans on his staff. FACT- Sanders and his campaign
KittyWampus
May 2015
#30
I stand by my original assessment of that kickoff. The optics were horrible for a "Democrat".
Tarheel_Dem
May 2015
#33
+1, omg yes... if that was an major corp and I was going in for a job interview I'd turn it down
uponit7771
May 2015
#129
To be honest, I don''t think this point has any bearing on the GE WRT Sanders.
MohRokTah
May 2015
#43
"The Problem that "insurgent" progressive Dem prez candidates tend to face is expanding their base
Cha
May 2015
#121
i still have one following along nipping at my heels, accusing me saying sanders is racist, cause i
seabeyond
May 2015
#146
i think he would also, and i think he would have no issue to listening. i do not think he is weak.
seabeyond
May 2015
#182
If he came to my town (in California no less) it would be mostly white people too.
Throd
May 2015
#70
Wait until the "Bernie Sanders is a rape-fantasy-writing misogynist" meme makes it here.
peecoolyour
May 2015
#82
if we talk racism, we are calling him a racist. if we talk misogyny issues, we are calling him a
seabeyond
May 2015
#87
No, there are conservative bloggers who found something he wrote decades ago.
peecoolyour
May 2015
#96
If I was to agree with the many post of Bernie being a racist, It would make me
Thinkingabout
May 2015
#90
Yes. We've long known a certain candidate fights dirty. And now we're seeing it. n/t
RufusTFirefly
May 2015
#140
I agree, but do you agree all the cheap shots aimed at Hillary are the same too?
B Calm
May 2015
#142
pro sanders created the racism conversation when others were merely discussing social justice.
seabeyond
May 2015
#164
chris hayes said the same. is he calling sanders a racist? i have been told i repeatedly call sander
seabeyond
May 2015
#166
It's "centrists" attempting to attack Sanders...from the Left. It's like your parents trying to be cool
Romulox
May 2015
#149
This is a subject fueled by his supporters, I am beginning they are trying to defend Bernie from
Thinkingabout
May 2015
#176
I started seeing posts about this yesterday mostly by his supporters claimng he wasn't racist, like
Thinkingabout
May 2015
#179