General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)WaPo Fact Checks President's Claim That States With Most Gun Laws Tend To Have Fewest Gun Deaths [View all]
Washington Post fact checkers give two Pinocchio's to President Obama's claim that states with the most gun laws tend to have the fewest gun deaths, which means the statement included "significant omissions and/or exaggerations," although the author notes he waivered between two and three Pinocchio's, with three being in the "mostly false" category. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/fact-checker/wp/2015/10/05/obamas-claim-that-states-with-the-most-gun-laws-tend-to-have-the-fewest-gun-deaths/?tid=pm_politics_pop_b
In the article the WaPo explains that when you exclude suicides, which account for 60% of gun deaths, then there is a significant change in where a state might rank in the number of gun deaths per 100,000 people.
First, the WaPo notes that the data is "mixed" on whether stricter gun laws lead to fewer suicides:
Japan, for instance, has among the worlds most-restrictive gun-control regimes and yet also has among the worlds highest suicide rates, almost double the U.S. suicide rate.
Second, once you exclude suicides:
Meanwhile, Maryland a more urban state fell from 15th place to 45th, even though it has very tough gun laws. Illinois dropped from 11th place to 38th, and New York fell from 3rd to 15th.
The WaPo concluded that:
In short, I, along with almost all of the people on DU, support toughening our gun laws to include UBCs and additional training. But stricter gun laws isn't the panacea it is made out to be, and in some states -- notably Maryland -- such laws have had little impact on gun violence.