Another person who dismisses a serious and sincere argument without deigning to comment. I (Reply #37)

In the discussion thread: Post removed [View all]

Response to yardwork (Reply #30)

Wed Oct 28, 2015, 08:44 PM

Monk06 (7,675 posts)

37. Another person who dismisses a serious and sincere argument without deigning to comment. I

guess a serious discussion on this topic is just not possible here

Cannot reply in removed threads

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

60 replies	Author	Time	Post
Post removed [View all]	Post removed	Oct 2015	OP
Greer is incorrect and an atavistic bigot. That's an opinion, not a prohibition.	Bluenorthwest	Oct 2015	#1
Maybe. Should Cardiff students be able to hear her views?	Comrade Grumpy	Oct 2015	#3
+1 I have zero patience with those who wear "being offended" as a badge of honor,	jonno99	Oct 2015	#5
Would you make the same argument about a virulent racist or homophobe?	Spider Jerusalem	Oct 2015	#6
I think universities are places to exchange views and perspectives.	Comrade Grumpy	Oct 2015	#12
So should they allow the KKK to give rallies there?	LostOne4Ever	Oct 2015	#16
Yeah, you're wrong.	Act_of_Reparation	Oct 2015	#59
New level needed: MIRT300. n/t	demmiblue	Oct 2015	#2
Nice example of the case the OP is making.	Comrade Grumpy	Oct 2015	#4
We nuke people for being racist so why not nuke a transphobe?	LostOne4Ever	Oct 2015	#15
Oh my goodness, what a pile of crap. I hardly know where to start.	LeftyMom	Oct 2015	#7
For the record, TERF = Trans-Exclusionary Radical Feminist.	KamaAina	Oct 2015	#8
TERF war. Heh.	Comrade Grumpy	Oct 2015	#13
But this ain't their TERF!	LostOne4Ever	Oct 2015	#17
They go Hand in Hand with SWERF	Lordquinton	Oct 2015	#23
No. This is leftwing biology denial and pseudoscience.	frizzled	Oct 2015	#9
Why does this matter so much to you?	yardwork	Oct 2015	#10
It's a short, philosophically sound, well reasoned argument. What makes it obsessional?	Monk06	Oct 2015	#20
It's not short and it's far from philsophoically sound...it's garbage...nt	joeybee12	Oct 2015	#25
Well you are correct in saying it is not, "philsophoically sound", (sorry couldn't resist lol) Your	Monk06	Oct 2015	#28
The whole thing is crap...	joeybee12	Oct 2015	#29
Not buying something is not arguing against it. It's Crap is not a counter arguement. The issue	Monk06	Oct 2015	#35
Your demand for a counter argument requires the original argument to be worth something.	stevenleser	Oct 2015	#44
Your refusal to provide a counter argument is in fact an argument. Unfortunately, an Ad Hominem	Monk06	Oct 2015	#48
Nope. Bigotry is automatically self-de-legitimizing. No explanation is needed. nt	stevenleser	Oct 2015	#49
+infinity (nt)	LostOne4Ever	Oct 2015	#50
What an awful post. Truly.	yardwork	Oct 2015	#30
It is a sickening post filled with tons of transphobic remarks and stereotypes nt	LostOne4Ever	Oct 2015	#32
Another person who dismisses a serious and sincere argument without deigning to comment. I	Monk06	Oct 2015	#37
See my #44. nt	stevenleser	Oct 2015	#45
It seems like you're a little unclear on a few basic concepts here.	LeftyMom	Oct 2015	#41
Well I have had these concepts explained to me before on these sorts of threads. I am not convinced	Monk06	Oct 2015	#43
Right on! nt	kelliekat44	Oct 2015	#24
THANK YOU	Skittles	Oct 2015	#55
Wait a minute.	LeftyMom	Oct 2015	#11
+infinity (nt)	LostOne4Ever	Oct 2015	#18
Your terf biology is full of crap, is denialism, and the real pseudoscience	LostOne4Ever	Oct 2015	#14
+1	Lordquinton	Oct 2015	#21
+1	Major Nikon	Oct 2015	#27
Thank you.	beam me up scottie	Oct 2015	#34
+1	Starry Messenger	Oct 2015	#36
Bravo! nt	LexVegas	Oct 2015	#40
Thanks for this - this is awesome.	bullwinkle428	Oct 2015	#42
Nailed it.	Agschmid	Oct 2015	#46
...	RedCappedBandit	Oct 2015	#56
Nicely done, as always.	Act_of_Reparation	Oct 2015	#57
I'm going to bookmark this under	Goblinmonger	Oct 2015	#19
I alerted on this horror of a post and it was upheld 4:3. Here are the results	stevenleser	Oct 2015	#47
It's not alleged transphobia, Greer IS a transphobe...	joeybee12	Oct 2015	#22
If a venue has a policy against giving air time to bigots, they're not being inconsistent.	Warren DeMontague	Oct 2015	#26
That kind of bullshit has been going on right here on DU	hifiguy	Oct 2015	#31
so if I say gay folk should not have the right to marry	Skittles	Oct 2015	#54
The term "identity politics" is bullshit	gollygee	Oct 2015	#33
I have found out right here on du	Lordquinton	Oct 2015	#51
Germaine Greer is a nasty and ignorant bigot.	Starry Messenger	Oct 2015	#38
Fuck this bigot and anyone that buys into this bullshit. nt	LexVegas	Oct 2015	#39
What a load of crap.	Gormy Cuss	Oct 2015	#52
sorry, no, I don't tolerate bigotry	Skittles	Oct 2015	#53
I wonder whatever possessed you to think this garbage belonged here.	stevenleser	Oct 2015	#58
Oh Bullshit	ismnotwasm	Oct 2015	#60

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.