General Discussion

braddy

(3,585 posts)

31. We have to assume it is a false claim, a fake claim of something that just isn't true, it didn't

Reply to Humanist_Activist (Reply #19)

Fri Jun 10, 2016, 07:36 PM

Jun 2016

ring true anyway.

Click here to purchase valentine hearts!

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

117 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

If A Woman Has Problem Pregnancy Catholic Hospitals Will Just Let Her Die. [View all] TheMastersNemesis Jun 2016 OP

Hmmm.....any data on this? Socal31 Jun 2016 #1

1 in 6 hospitals is catholic, resulting in lowered reproductive care for women. niyad Jun 2016 #3

None of those back up the assertion that doctors are letting women die. Socal31 Jun 2016 #4

you keep telling yourself that. oh, and read the articles. niyad Jun 2016 #5

Not how it works, sorry. Socal31 Jun 2016 #7

Try this. MH1 Jun 2016 #10

"The church won't allow doctors to terminate ectopic pregnancies until a woman is in mortal danger" MH1 Jun 2016 #12

Again, I'm not seeing any reports of women dying, they should be easy to link. Socal31 Jun 2016 #17

Please see my comment #18 MH1 Jun 2016 #20

I believe it happened in Ireland. Ilsa Jun 2016 #32

You've been disproved. I can't wait to see your amends. BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2016 #44

What happens in Catholic and other hospitals Hortensis Jun 2016 #109

I've read them. Where do they say they let women die? n/t pnwmom Jun 2016 #8

Please see my responses to the prior comment. nt MH1 Jun 2016 #13

please see my post just ahead of yours. nt Ilsa Jun 2016 #33

Here's some links: Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #9

Here. cleanhippie Jun 2016 #46

This makes me absolutely furious! smirkymonkey Jun 2016 #2

Omg, I'm so sorry smirkymonkey. BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2016 #45

Thank you Blanche. smirkymonkey Jun 2016 #78

Please show one U.S. case where this has happened. pnwmom Jun 2016 #6

From my research, they wait until they nearly die, then save them... Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #14

... BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2016 #116

It doesn't ileus Jun 2016 #58

Your first paragraph is pure bullshit. rug Jun 2016 #11

Actually, examining some of the cases, they actually do... Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #16

You are equating an abortion with the only treatment available. rug Jun 2016 #22

Not as long as there's a fetal heartbeat, according to the links I've posted MH1 Jun 2016 #26

I want to see United States proof. Not some foreign country yeoman6987 Jun 2016 #34

"...foreign country" greiner3 Jun 2016 #38

And that is why nobody is taking your OP seriously. yeoman6987 Jun 2016 #42

The only people not taking this seriously are Church apologists who value their religion... Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #59

Nonsense. yeoman6987 Jun 2016 #61

Nice rebuttal Mr. "They can always go to another hospital" n/t Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #66

Here cleanhippie Jun 2016 #48

According to the documents provided by the USCCB in addition to actual case studies, Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #28

Read the link, the official ethic, I posted above. rug Jun 2016 #29

I think we all know Official Ethics rarely translate to Actual Practices. BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2016 #47

"proportionately serious" that's a problem, basically they won't terminate until the women's... Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #71

religious hospitals should lose their mercuryblues Jun 2016 #87

another one mercuryblues Jun 2016 #90

Hmm. MH1 Jun 2016 #18

You clearly haven't kept up. rug Jun 2016 #21

Where does that say she wasn't excommunicated for authorizing a life saving procedure? MH1 Jun 2016 #23

It was lifted. rug Jun 2016 #27

I'm sure the women who were forced to suffer or die BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2016 #88

Who died in that hospital? rug Jun 2016 #89

We are talking about massive amounts of human suffering. BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2016 #91

Outrage? rug Jun 2016 #108

I guess you're the kind of person who focuses on one narrow point... BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2016 #110

No, I'm the kind of person who sifts bullshit from fact before popping off. rug Jun 2016 #111

So far your claim isn't holding up, no one on the thread can prove what you are claiming. braddy Jun 2016 #15

Well, that just isn't true, several links to several cases and a meta-analysis published in a... Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #19

We have to assume it is a false claim, a fake claim of something that just isn't true, it didn't braddy Jun 2016 #31

Read the thread...there are women telling their experiences. BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2016 #49

Their experiences do not support the fake claim of the the thread, so your post doesn't make sense. braddy Jun 2016 #52

Bullshit BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2016 #54

Evidently not, this is a ridiculous thread, the OP proved to be nonsense. braddy Jun 2016 #55

It hasn't been proved to be nonsense, where is your evidence for that? Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #57

Where is your proof that this BS nonsense is factual? Here is your claim you are trying to make. braddy Jun 2016 #63

So your problem is with the thread title? Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #65

A claim was made as a thread topic, and it was fake, the thread is nonsense. braddy Jun 2016 #67

There is evidence of medical neglect due to religious interference. Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #69

When you can prove the claim of the thread title then post it. braddy Jun 2016 #70

Honestly, I can't prove it, at least not in the United States, may be due to lack of reporting on... Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #72

I know you can't prove it, it is a silly claim and a silly thread. You constantly posting to me is braddy Jun 2016 #74

So being concerned about women's reproductive health care is silly? Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #92

Don't start lying about me, when you can prove the silly fake claim of the OP is true, then post it braddy Jun 2016 #95

The worst you can say about it is that its hyperbole, but it isn't silly.. Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #96

Evidently this childish repetitive posting is something you live for, how about quit pestering me braddy Jun 2016 #98

Who is be repetitious here? Instead of responding to the content of my posts, many of which are.. Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #99

LOL, evidently this is what you do for kicks, good luck with your fake claim of the OP. braddy Jun 2016 #100

I was stuck with a doctor with privileges at a catholic hospital Let me bleed for two days while Person 2713 Jun 2016 #24

:( Duppers Jun 2016 #39

... BlancheSplanchnik Jun 2016 #50

I am so sorry for your experience. smirkymonkey Jun 2016 #79

I almost bleed to death at a Catholic hospital in Greensboro, NC yrs ago womanofthehills Jun 2016 #85

I had a D&C at a Catholic hospital in 1962---a friend of mine did also. virgogal Jun 2016 #86

Were you pregnant? Were you miscarrying but the ovum or fetus had not yet expelled? Person 2713 Jun 2016 #106

Yes,I miscarried but don't remember the details---sorry. virgogal Jun 2016 #117

My niece had a similar issue. Texasgal Jun 2016 #112

Must have just popped into your head just to start a thread? demosincebirth Jun 2016 #25

Well then let's just it decertify sarisataka Jun 2016 #30

Good question. There is no way communities could afford them yeoman6987 Jun 2016 #35

They will. My mother nearly died in a Catholic hospital Aerows Jun 2016 #36

Yeah, they like to send those orphaned boy babies to the Vatican for "special care." valerief Jun 2016 #37

Seriously now that I think about it wasn't the church in the orphan business at one time too? Person 2713 Jun 2016 #41

Post removed Post removed Jun 2016 #43

Have you ever watched the film "The Cardinale"? Omaha Steve Jun 2016 #40

you got a link?. Who has died in a USA hospital because treatment was withheld/refused? Sunlei Jun 2016 #51

Gee, why so much support for Catholic hospitals, which clearly deny needed care? alarimer Jun 2016 #53

Regardless of your personal feelings, the majority of communities could not yeoman6987 Jun 2016 #60

Then that makes it more important to make sure these hospitals comply with.... Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #68

It happens a lot then I assume. ileus Jun 2016 #56

There's a post on this very thread of a DUer who was allowed to bleed for 2 days because of this... Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #62

and the gop yanmners about death panels dembotoz Jun 2016 #64

I guess the lovefest for the Catholic Church is over with now BainsBane Jun 2016 #73

Real simple don't go to a Catholic Hospital. dilby Jun 2016 #75

That's just great if you live in a large city. Ilsa Jun 2016 #81

They've been buying up a lot of rural hospitals the last few years. Lars39 Jun 2016 #82

This is why I am a proud SCantiGOP Jun 2016 #76

Actually, that is not true. The largest Catholic hospital chain even covers birth control tonyt53 Jun 2016 #77

Only one chain, or does that apply to all of them? nt Ilsa Jun 2016 #83

Is that for the employees? Its for the employees, isn't it? Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #94

The OP is about treatment of problem pregnancies. Birth control is used to prevent pregnancy Person 2713 Jun 2016 #107

Isn't it bad enough that they refuse pregnancy prophylaxis to rape victims? Ilsa Jun 2016 #80

My... deathrind Jun 2016 #84

I am a retired nurse Runningdawg Jun 2016 #93

So the people who are coming forward with their stories are making them up? n/t Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #97

I do not have enough information to make that call Runningdawg Jun 2016 #104

I think the issue is mostly about the five women who experience what they did in a relatively short. Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #105

Another day on DU - more 840high Jun 2016 #101

Oh please, that's bullshit, when policies are put in place that put real people in harm... Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #102

I don't see much Isis, Taliban criticism here. Nor 840high Jun 2016 #113

Get out of here about your irrelevant bullshit... Humanist_Activist Jun 2016 #115

Yep libodem Jun 2016 #103

This again? ucrdem Jun 2016 #114