Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Large capacity magazines [View all]Straw Man
(6,952 posts)60. Correction.
NY has passed a similar law to what you propose after sandy hook - 10 round limit (7 round load limit was deemed unconstitutional), on new mags, with no real grandfathering, but w/registration of existing mags (same with expanded-defined assault weapons).
The NY SAFE Act did not allow grandfathering and registration of existing 10+ mags, except for curio & relic magazines. The law is confusingly worded, and no one is sure exactly what is legal and what isn't. If you call the state police, they tell you that they "don't give legal advice."
See if you can decipher this:
A FEEDING DEVICE THAT IS A CURIO OR RELIC IS DEFINED AS A DEVICE THAT (I)WAS MANUFACTURED AT LEAST FIFTY YEARS PRIOR TO THE CURRENT DATE, (II) IS ONLY CAPABLE OF BEING USED EXCLUSIVELY IN A FIREARM, RIFLE, OR SHOTGUN THAT WAS MANUFACTURED AT LEAST FIFTY YEARS PRIOR TO THE CURRENT DATE, BUT NOT INCLUDING REPLICAS THEREOF.
There is grandfathering and registration of currently-owned "assault weapons." A lot of people chose instead to render their ARs, etc., compliant by adding weirdo non-pistol-grip stocks, fixed magazines, etc. The idea is that they don't trust the state not to one day use registration lists for confiscation.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
65 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
I think the biggest problem is that the proposals are always reactionary and useless
Corporate666
Jun 2016
#56
FYI, there are billions of "large capacity" magazines already in circulation.
Just reading posts
Jun 2016
#2
KInd of hard to repair the levee when a lake has formed on top of it.
Just reading posts
Jun 2016
#8
There's also billions of grenades out there. We should just say fuck it and make them legal again.
Major Nikon
Jun 2016
#19
When have grenades been available for purchase on the open market for civilians in the modern era?
Marengo
Jun 2016
#44
One thing magazines currently in circulation probably number into the tens of millions. You can
doc03
Jun 2016
#3
Wouldn't argue that point, was at Cabelas a couple days ago. You have to draw a number and wait
doc03
Jun 2016
#10
You can also 3D print a machine gun receiver. We still do not allow their unfettered sale. NT
Adrahil
Jun 2016
#29
Note that some states currently limit magazine size and the "assault weapon ban"
PoliticAverse
Jun 2016
#5
Large cap mags have been restricted in the past, and currently are in several states.
jmg257
Jun 2016
#13
The way I read the relic mags would be say a 15rounder for M1 carbine...nice relic, but they make
jmg257
Jun 2016
#63
I wouldn't take chances...original $1500 S'G' with a pair of original 70yr old SG mags...
jmg257
Jun 2016
#65
You have a point. The thing about AR15 that makes them useful to mass shooters is their
aikoaiko
Jun 2016
#15
I'd much prefer an AR for accuracy and terminal ballistics than a shotgun in most situations.
aikoaiko
Jun 2016
#26
A knowledgable poster may be along shortly to inform you a Daisy BB rifle is more effective.
Marengo
Jun 2016
#45
An AR-15 is not going to penetrate the brick of my house, then go through by neighbors house
Travis_0004
Jun 2016
#55
"...make them harder to find - especially for people who are flaky outsiders in our society ..."
Angel Martin
Jun 2016
#35
Kind of. Normal capacity magazines were legal to sell if they were made prior to 1994.
Just reading posts
Jun 2016
#42