General Discussion

NightWatcher

(39,376 posts)

37. Just as many different groups have flood myths too. Christianity is not original

Sat Dec 24, 2016, 09:50 AM

Dec 2016

"Jesus" wasn't born in December but Christians incorporated local celebrations and mixed them into their myth. Easter originally was about spring rebirth and fertility before they threw his resurrection myth into the local's celebration.

Click here to purchase valentine hearts!

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

68 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

5,000-year-old "nativity scene" reportedly found in Egypt [View all] mfcorey1 Dec 2016 OP

Were xtians 5000 years ago? yortsed snacilbuper Dec 2016 #1

They were eating dinosaur. AngryAmish Dec 2016 #2

You are talking about a Hebrew story (Noah) Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #4

No. This PREDATES Christianity. Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #3

this predates Mithraism and Judaism Bucky Dec 2016 #44

I did not say that these images were representative of Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #55

Fascinating Sanity Claws Dec 2016 #5

That would be cool, huh? Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #10

But were there shoppers? milestogo Dec 2016 #6

Ha! Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #11

Interpreting an image is highly affected by what the viewer has known and experienced. TexasProgresive Dec 2016 #7

I agree. It is too old for us to ever be Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #12

Agreed LW1977 Dec 2016 #20

Well, while true that most Americans think of a Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #23

The baby looks like a wine bottle with the corkscrew still in it... elehhhhna Dec 2016 #33

Proof that children have always led parents to drink! Bucky Dec 2016 #45

the baby is flying. Must be Jesus. elehhhhna Dec 2016 #35

This message was self-deleted by its author edhopper Dec 2016 #30

Merry Horusmas ? Achilleaze Dec 2016 #8

Agree. That would be the most obvious connection, given Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #13

The image predates that story by close to 1000 years TexasProgresive Dec 2016 #14

So far as we know. Many stories have origins in Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #18

As far as we know- That's just it when it comes to prehistory we make lots of assumptions. TexasProgresive Dec 2016 #19

Yep, that is the nature of the social sciences. When we Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #21

It's a short story. Watch the video. It should be the whole thing. TexasProgresive Dec 2016 #22

OK. Will do later! Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #28

Just as many different groups have flood myths too. Christianity is not original NightWatcher Dec 2016 #37

I always figured that the proliferation of the flood myths... Wounded Bear Dec 2016 #66

Weren't most of the Greek heroes also of "virgin birth"... Wounded Bear Dec 2016 #47

Absolutely! rusty fender Dec 2016 #53

Actually, none of them were. okasha Dec 2016 #59

So did Mary... Wounded Bear Dec 2016 #63

Dear Bear, okasha Dec 2016 #67

GA Wells is the most well respected scholar on Jesus Drahthaardogs Dec 2016 #60

Maybe so... Wounded Bear Dec 2016 #64

Doubt it Drahthaardogs Dec 2016 #65

The story of Jesus is not an original work. JNelson6563 Dec 2016 #9

There are very few sacred stories that do not contain Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #16

"The cave was universally identified with the womb of Mother Earth..." Donkees Dec 2016 #15

Caves symbolize many things. Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #17

My response is in context to the conversation concerning 'nativity scene'... Donkees Dec 2016 #24

Understood. Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #26

Discussing this research near the time of the winter solstice, brings to mind the myths of sun-god Donkees Dec 2016 #29

Yes, this is true. Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #38

This is not a Nativity scene... Mike Nelson Dec 2016 #25

Who knows?!? Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #27

I see man, woman and child edhopper Dec 2016 #31

Seems like a reach? MineralMan Dec 2016 #32

I think you misunderstood my post edhopper Dec 2016 #34

OK. Well, people are always looking for some MineralMan Dec 2016 #39

Cave paintings edhopper Dec 2016 #41

How do we know it's a child pintobean Dec 2016 #42

There is no evidence edhopper Dec 2016 #43

It was a tongue in cheek question pintobean Dec 2016 #46

I should have put a wink edhopper Dec 2016 #50

Maybe next year we won't have to suffer thru X-mas. ileus Dec 2016 #36

So is your attitude. calendargirl Dec 2016 #40

That's no child... TCJ70 Dec 2016 #48

Auditioning for a job on the History Channel? LeftyMom Dec 2016 #58

My hair isn't crazy enough to be on Ancient Aliens... TCJ70 Dec 2016 #61

The word "nativity" doesn't necessarily refer to the birth of Christ. WillowTree Dec 2016 #49

Acoss from the left hand of the man on my right. Although it is not a star on high in the sky lunasun Dec 2016 #51

"Kilroy" strikes again Historic NY Dec 2016 #52

Most of the Christian stories were taken WhiteTara Dec 2016 #54

I figured out what it means, yortsed snacilbuper Dec 2016 #56

Looks like two people and a kid to me, and a headless cow Blaukraut Dec 2016 #57

What I see is a man, a woman and a child Douglas Kawasaki Dec 2016 #62

Well... you know what this means, don't you? Warren DeMontague Dec 2016 #68