General Discussion

Warren DeMontague

(80,708 posts)

68. Well... you know what this means, don't you?

Reply to mfcorey1 (Original post)

Sun Dec 25, 2016, 09:23 PM

Dec 2016

probably not a whole lot.

Click here to purchase valentine hearts!

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

68 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

5,000-year-old "nativity scene" reportedly found in Egypt [View all] mfcorey1 Dec 2016 OP

Were xtians 5000 years ago? yortsed snacilbuper Dec 2016 #1

They were eating dinosaur. AngryAmish Dec 2016 #2

You are talking about a Hebrew story (Noah) Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #4

No. This PREDATES Christianity. Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #3

this predates Mithraism and Judaism Bucky Dec 2016 #44

I did not say that these images were representative of Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #55

Fascinating Sanity Claws Dec 2016 #5

That would be cool, huh? Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #10

But were there shoppers? milestogo Dec 2016 #6

Ha! Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #11

Interpreting an image is highly affected by what the viewer has known and experienced. TexasProgresive Dec 2016 #7

I agree. It is too old for us to ever be Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #12

Agreed LW1977 Dec 2016 #20

Well, while true that most Americans think of a Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #23

The baby looks like a wine bottle with the corkscrew still in it... elehhhhna Dec 2016 #33

Proof that children have always led parents to drink! Bucky Dec 2016 #45

the baby is flying. Must be Jesus. elehhhhna Dec 2016 #35

This message was self-deleted by its author edhopper Dec 2016 #30

Merry Horusmas ? Achilleaze Dec 2016 #8

Agree. That would be the most obvious connection, given Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #13

The image predates that story by close to 1000 years TexasProgresive Dec 2016 #14

So far as we know. Many stories have origins in Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #18

As far as we know- That's just it when it comes to prehistory we make lots of assumptions. TexasProgresive Dec 2016 #19

Yep, that is the nature of the social sciences. When we Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #21

It's a short story. Watch the video. It should be the whole thing. TexasProgresive Dec 2016 #22

OK. Will do later! Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #28

Just as many different groups have flood myths too. Christianity is not original NightWatcher Dec 2016 #37

I always figured that the proliferation of the flood myths... Wounded Bear Dec 2016 #66

Weren't most of the Greek heroes also of "virgin birth"... Wounded Bear Dec 2016 #47

Absolutely! rusty fender Dec 2016 #53

Actually, none of them were. okasha Dec 2016 #59

So did Mary... Wounded Bear Dec 2016 #63

Dear Bear, okasha Dec 2016 #67

GA Wells is the most well respected scholar on Jesus Drahthaardogs Dec 2016 #60

Maybe so... Wounded Bear Dec 2016 #64

Doubt it Drahthaardogs Dec 2016 #65

The story of Jesus is not an original work. JNelson6563 Dec 2016 #9

There are very few sacred stories that do not contain Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #16

"The cave was universally identified with the womb of Mother Earth..." Donkees Dec 2016 #15

Caves symbolize many things. Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #17

My response is in context to the conversation concerning 'nativity scene'... Donkees Dec 2016 #24

Understood. Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #26

Discussing this research near the time of the winter solstice, brings to mind the myths of sun-god Donkees Dec 2016 #29

Yes, this is true. Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #38

This is not a Nativity scene... Mike Nelson Dec 2016 #25

Who knows?!? Silver Gaia Dec 2016 #27

I see man, woman and child edhopper Dec 2016 #31

Seems like a reach? MineralMan Dec 2016 #32

I think you misunderstood my post edhopper Dec 2016 #34

OK. Well, people are always looking for some MineralMan Dec 2016 #39

Cave paintings edhopper Dec 2016 #41

How do we know it's a child pintobean Dec 2016 #42

There is no evidence edhopper Dec 2016 #43

It was a tongue in cheek question pintobean Dec 2016 #46

I should have put a wink edhopper Dec 2016 #50

Maybe next year we won't have to suffer thru X-mas. ileus Dec 2016 #36

So is your attitude. calendargirl Dec 2016 #40

That's no child... TCJ70 Dec 2016 #48

Auditioning for a job on the History Channel? LeftyMom Dec 2016 #58

My hair isn't crazy enough to be on Ancient Aliens... TCJ70 Dec 2016 #61

The word "nativity" doesn't necessarily refer to the birth of Christ. WillowTree Dec 2016 #49

Acoss from the left hand of the man on my right. Although it is not a star on high in the sky lunasun Dec 2016 #51

"Kilroy" strikes again Historic NY Dec 2016 #52

Most of the Christian stories were taken WhiteTara Dec 2016 #54

I figured out what it means, yortsed snacilbuper Dec 2016 #56

Looks like two people and a kid to me, and a headless cow Blaukraut Dec 2016 #57

What I see is a man, a woman and a child Douglas Kawasaki Dec 2016 #62

Well... you know what this means, don't you? Warren DeMontague Dec 2016 #68