Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

TygrBright

(21,400 posts)
16. It's a lovely concept in the small scale, but the messaging is confusing.
Mon Feb 13, 2017, 12:58 PM
Feb 2017

What this REALLY is, is what fundraisers call a 'premium' for a donation- a thank-you gift of real monetary value, the amount of which needs to be deducted from tax-deductible portion of the gift.

It's most unlikely that the hoodie cost that much to manufacture, even using Union American labor. The amount it DID cost should simply be deducted and the rest of the $90 receipted as a charitable gift that the donor may write off on their tax return.

It does nothing to "make America great" to foster the idea that the cost of American-made goods would be so great as to put them out of reach for people on limited budgets.

EITHER Ashley needs to clarify that this is fund-raising, pure and simple, or she needs to re-structure the deal so that people have the option of purchasing it at the actual manufacturing price plus markups to cover fulfillment and indirect costs, as well as the option of purchasing it at that price plus making a separate donation that will bring the cost up to $90.

Objective: Win

Implementation: Fail

It would be a much bigger and better "Make America Great" project to provide seed capital and startup assistance for worker-owned co-ops to manufacture consumer goods and sell them at a price point within reach of people willing to pay more than WalMart prices for American-made goods, but still not able to buy premium stuff.

helpfully,
Bright

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

$90 hoodies are not the way to do it. RedWedge Feb 2017 #1
I think it's a lot too! Phentex Feb 2017 #3
That was my reaction, too. Ms. Toad Feb 2017 #4
don't, many of us will heaven05 Feb 2017 #13
I choose directly where to donate my money. Ms. Toad Feb 2017 #24
excuse noted heaven05 Feb 2017 #25
It's not an excuse. That's how I manage my charitable donations. Ms. Toad Feb 2017 #28
well, good for you heaven05 Feb 2017 #32
the money goes to charity JI7 Feb 2017 #6
yeah, well don't buy one!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! heaven05 Feb 2017 #12
+100 Hekate Feb 2017 #14
Class is always quite Botany Feb 2017 #2
I'm not surprised that Joe's children are service oriented. brer cat Feb 2017 #5
Unfortunately, some of us cannot afford $90.00 for a hoodie no justhanginon Feb 2017 #7
considering the responses so far, it is necessary. mopinko Feb 2017 #8
Very good point PatSeg Feb 2017 #11
Except that I expect many of us decline the book or DVD Ms. Toad Feb 2017 #29
Personally, I don't care for goodies PatSeg Feb 2017 #33
Yup, Mo, me, too. dmr Feb 2017 #19
BINGO. Those who can - should. calimary Feb 2017 #20
There are many things I can't afford brer cat Feb 2017 #10
I agree. Ms. Toad Feb 2017 #30
This is such a good family PatSeg Feb 2017 #9
I would think of it as a donation to charity that comes with a free hoodie IronLionZion Feb 2017 #15
It's a lovely concept in the small scale, but the messaging is confusing. TygrBright Feb 2017 #16
Very helpful, Bright Hekate Feb 2017 #18
oh stop it. mopinko Feb 2017 #23
I'm sorry if it came off that way. But an important principle IS at stake. TygrBright Feb 2017 #26
i dont see any deceit here. mopinko Feb 2017 #27
Excellent response. Ms. Toad Feb 2017 #31
The Bidens continue to make me proud. I'll bet there's a way to make a direct donation of $20... Hekate Feb 2017 #17
Why did we not make Trump's hypocracy on trade a bigger issue? hollowdweller Feb 2017 #21
Actually, the cost PRETZEL Feb 2017 #22
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Bidens Daughter Just Show...»Reply #16