Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Latest Breaking News

Showing Original Post only (View all)

BumRushDaShow

(129,043 posts)
Mon Feb 19, 2024, 06:11 AM Feb 19

Alabama Supreme Court Rules That Frozen Embryos Are 'Children' [View all]

Source: Huff Post

Feb 18, 2024, 11:01 PM EST


The Alabama Supreme Court ruled Friday that frozen embryos are children, which pro-choice rights groups have warned could have dangerous implications for fertility treatments such as in vitro fertilization.

The Alabama Supreme Court on Friday reversed Mobile County Circuit Court Judge Jill Parrish Phillips’ decision to dismiss a lawsuit in which a couple sued an Alabama fertility clinic and hospital for the “wrongful death” of their frozen embryos in a ruling that was riddled with theology. The couple’s frozen embryos were destroyed after a hospital patient who accessed the freezer that held the embryos dropped them on the floor. The ruling means that the couple can sue for wrongful death.

“[T]he Wrongful Death of a Minor Act is sweeping and unqualified. It applies to all children, born and unborn, without limitation,” the ruling said. “It is not the role of this Court to craft a new limitation based on our own view of what is or is not wise public policy. That is especially true where, as here, the People of this State have adopted a Constitutional amendment directly aimed at stopping courts from excluding ‘unborn life’ from legal protection.”

The ruling pointed to the Alabama Constitution Section 36.06, which argues that each person was made in God’s image, meaning each life has an incalculable value that “cannot be wrongfully destroyed without incurring the wrath of a holy God.”

Read more: https://www.huffpost.com/entry/alabama-ruling-frozen-embryos-children_n_65d29a77e4b043f1c0aba2b9?nmq

52 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
So, then by the "logic" of the AL Supreme Court, if a freezer holding frozen embryos no_hypocrisy Feb 19 #1
That's a big ramification of this. BumRushDaShow Feb 19 #2
The entire Gulf Coast is clusterfuck sponsored by the Republican clowns of the apocalypse. Magoo48 Feb 19 #34
Just fly into Disney, give them your money, then GTFO wolfie001 Feb 19 #36
Should spawn an embryo tax-deduction Trust Fund, IRA, Social Security, Stim Check scheme bucolic_frolic Feb 19 #3
Deductions for college savings accounts - perhaps the state will kick in some matching funds EYESORE 9001 Feb 19 #4
Every "child/embryo" should count in the census for the state they are located BumRushDaShow Feb 19 #5
"But officer, I'm not violating the carpool lane laws. MurrayDelph Feb 20 #43
"Hey, Honey? Let's freeze some tax deductions." vanlassie Feb 19 #6
No shit. progressoid Feb 19 #9
If they were alive, freezing them would be child abuse. raging moderate Feb 19 #13
so if they place that keeps them frozen loses power and the embryos are not longer viable... Javaman Feb 19 #7
Not so much murder EmmaLee E Feb 19 #39
I'm ready to get flak for this... Trueblue Texan Feb 19 #8
I've got 2 1st cousins that used in vitro fertilization. maxsolomon Feb 19 #20
belief in illogical things can be a virtue in Catholicism DBoon Feb 19 #27
Next up from AL, women accused of 'wrongful death' in every period cycle. apnu Feb 19 #10
And The State Hasn't Earned The Nickname... GB_RN Feb 19 #31
Wouldn't that also be considered manslaughter? Squaredeal Feb 19 #11
"After a divorce, does an ex-spouse have the right to the embryos and collect child support" BumRushDaShow Feb 19 #12
God's image? What the fuckin' fuck is that? twodogsbarking Feb 19 #14
Torah FORBIDS images of God. Grins Feb 19 #19
Embryos are frozen until needed... CCExile Feb 19 #15
freezers aren't built to last that long DBoon Feb 19 #28
For the purpose of this discussion is the embryo and egg or a fertilized egg in the true biological sense? usaf-vet Feb 19 #29
Small towns could now afford zoos of their own. Or have a traveling zoo in a box! Wonder Why Feb 19 #32
So, will someone now be challenging AL's death penalty? area51 Feb 19 #16
Hell naw! Rethuglicans only care about people BEFORE they're born. OMGWTF Feb 19 #22
Yup! NowsTheTime Feb 19 #41
Monty said it 50 yrs ago... k55f5r Feb 19 #17
"...a hospital patient who...dropped them on the floor" Grins Feb 19 #18
An accident. They thought it was where the staff kept the ice cream containers and they wanted some butter pecan. Wonder Why Feb 19 #33
Really? You can't put a baby in the freezer. OMGWTF Feb 19 #21
Tax deductions ! republianmushroom Feb 19 #23
My thoughts as well. SergeStorms Feb 19 #24
What about the millions of sperm spilled daily by each man in AL? I could go much further on "wasted" sperm. keopeli Feb 19 #25
My thoughts exactly. I mean it is half a baby, right? Chainfire Feb 19 #26
This is perfect for those white nationalists BaronChocula Feb 19 #30
Elle Woods put it best in "Legally Blonde" LastLiberal in PalmSprings Feb 19 #35
Could an embryo get a license to carry a gun Marthe48 Feb 19 #37
So the buildings on fire, you can only save one. Live little baby lying in a crib or a box holding a hundred embryos. OverBurn Feb 19 #38
I read the title incorrectly... Layzeebeaver Feb 19 #40
Alabama Constitution Section 36.06, which argues that each person was made in God's image pfitz59 Feb 19 #42
So based on that. Old Crank Feb 20 #45
I checked and ... SomewhereInTheMiddle Feb 21 #49
Yeah; the judge implied the "image of God" stuff from one use of "Almighty God" in the preamble muriel_volestrangler Feb 21 #52
So when the companies in AL which do this shut down Old Crank Feb 20 #44
Truly idiotic, stupid and moronic SouthernDem4ever Feb 20 #46
now texas is arguing a fetus isn't a baby and doesn't have rights republianmushroom Feb 20 #47
The reliance on types of Christianity in the ruling is worse than the Huff Post report says muriel_volestrangler Feb 21 #48
Their Chief Justice: dalton99a Feb 21 #50
Al Abama. Yoga was not allowed in public schools for 30 years. underpants Feb 21 #51
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Alabama Supreme Court Rul...