Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: This message was self-deleted by its author [View all]Lugal Zaggesi
(366 posts)169. Your thinking is muddled
You didn't read the article about the 95 year old Senior Olympics athlete. Mike Kilmer was NOT an "athlete" in his youth:
Kilmer noted that he wasnt especially athletic in his youth. He began jogging in his 70s and competed in his first Olympics soon afterward.
"Being an "athlete" when one is young can mean that those body parts are getting worn down quicker--resulting in spinal degeneration and a hunched appearance." - thanks for that irrelevant observation - Mike Kilmer started *jogging* - not exactly NFL football - when he was in his 70's.
You apparently have no idea how OLD 95 really is:
There isnt anybody as old as I am still doing this, he said. For some reason or other, Im still here at 95. Most of the people whore 95 years old cant hardly get around at all. When I first started out, of course, there were quite a few in my age group, but they kind of thinned out as I got older and now there isnt anybody. I havent seen anybody in the Senior Olympics in the last 10 years in my age group.
http://health.usnews.com/health-news/family-health/boomer-health/articles/2011/11/17/more-americans-living-to-90-us-census-finds
Nonagenarians were 0.6 % of the US population in 2010. Most of them -- 74 percent -- are women, particularly white women who live alone or in nursing homes, according to the report. Most have one or more disabilities. Most (85 percent) of those 90 and older say they have one or more physical limitations. About 66 percent have difficulty walking or climbing stairs. 95 years old is the OLDER half of 90-99.
As for your "horseback riding, hiking residents" - 95 is as much older than 62 as 36 is older than 3. There are not many 36 year olds checked into toddler day care centers. A lot happens in 33 years.
[center]
[/center]
Now let's talk about John Warna's reason for being so upset in the first place - he was involuntarily being stuffed into an ambulance on Friday night for medical treatment - show me one citation that staff was trying to transport this guy to the mental hospital - you made that up. His "assisted living" Nursing Home had decided he needed to be brought to a hospital for medical treatment, and he refused to go that Friday night - maybe he wanted to watch a baseball game on TV. Yet the staff felt they had the right to force him to go - so much for your "assisted living" assertions - for John Warna, this was a nursing home. "We decide. You obey."
"they wouldn't be smart enough to cough up a "faked" story about a knife ... BEFORE the guy even died."
According to an e-mailed press release from Park Forest police, officers were sent to 101 Main Street in Park Forest about 8:42 p.m. Friday to help a private ambulance company with a combative resident of the home there Warna.
Why was the Police Department emailing out press releases to news organizations on Saturday ? Because local news organizations had gotten hold of the story that a 95 year old was tasered/shotgun-blasted by cops, and died a few hours later.
Here's the first local story:
http://southtownstar.suntimes.com/21566128-522/police-knife-wielding-senior-citizen-dies-after-being-tasered-hit-with-bean-bag-rounds.html
BY ALLISON HORTON Staff Reporter/ahorton@suntimes.com July 27, 2013 11:57AM
John Warna - tasered/blasted Friday night, died Saturday 2:30 am, reporters on the story that Saturday morning, Park Forest police respond with an emailed "press release" that morning in response to inquiries. Cops know they will look very bad if they killed (and it's been ruled a homicide, by the way) a 95 year old wielding only a cane and a shoe horn. So what's the worst weapon they could claim he grabbed when they ordered him to accept his involuntary ambulance ride ? A "butcher" knife. So that's what they claim.
http://southtownstar.suntimes.com/21604323-522/death-of-man-95-tasered-by-police-is-ruled-a-homicide.html
The Illinois State Police Public Integrity Unit is reviewing the shooting incident.
Uh-oh - they will want witnesses to this alleged "butcher knife" attack. They will ask if Mr. Warna was cutting up whole chickens and vegetables in his "assisted living" nursing home room, or if he was a pudding-in-the-cafeteria guy. They will investigate why a taser that can stop NFL players didn't at least slow down the 95 year old Mr. Warna. The cops are going to have to pull in some favors, put out some threats... Too bad "Police Public Integrity Units" don't have a good reputation for going after police abuse, I'd love to see a real investigation of what happened, with photos.
[center]
[/center]
I find it very suspicious that the man who desperately didn't want to be stuffed in an ambulance Friday night was fighting off staff and ambulance drivers with a cane and a shoehorn, but when the cops arrived. And tasered him - but to "no effect" they claimed (what, the old guy has a faulty nervous system?). And shotgunned him. It turned out that all along, he merely had to "drop the shoehorn and grab a 12-inch butcher knife". What ? There was a butcher knife within reach that whole time he struggled with staff and burly ambulance drivers, but he forgot to grab it ? Come on.
I bet the back-dated police report will show that only the police were in the room when the "butcher knife" was pulled, because the staff and ambulance drivers had retreated to a safe distance out in the hall, away from the Fists of Fury 95-year-old. There will be no witnesses of the alleged "butcher knife" incident, but the cops will magically find such a knife in a large living complex, and say "yup, that's the knife. Nothing we could do. Had to shotgun him with lead from 8 feet, nothing else we could do. The old black guy was just a fighting machine - the Taser didn't even slow him down." I would also bet the original report was lost, and a nice, neat new one was filed Saturday afternoon, after contacting all the news organizations.
Cannot edit, recommend, or reply in locked discussions
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
199 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Those are not cops... those are pigs. Plain and simple. A cop would have been reasonable. n/t
nebenaube
Jul 2013
#1
We can expect that they'll make up some story that they thought that he would hurt himself.
AnotherMcIntosh
Jul 2013
#51
If seems to be one of those after-the-fact knives. A drop knife. It is inconsistent with the
AnotherMcIntosh
Jul 2013
#52
A 12 inch drop knife? A butcher knife? From a guy who lived in an apartment at an elderly
MADem
Jul 2013
#75
There are a tiny handful of martial arts masters in their 90s, but this was not one of those cases.
Kennah
Jul 2013
#18
My native Japanese Kendo Master is 72 years old and can mop the floor with anyone in our Dojo
Katashi_itto
Jul 2013
#34
The staff at his assisted living facility had called an ambulance to involuntarily commit him.
MADem
Jul 2013
#25
It doesn't appear there was much training, because if their was, I would think it would of involved
midnight
Jul 2013
#37
Our population is aging and needs qualified people who won't ramp up a situation into this
midnight
Jul 2013
#137
So...you're saying it was okay to let a crazy, violent man run around an elderly apartment
MADem
Jul 2013
#72
Will do! Considering I live in Harlem and I'm Black. It's pretty much a given. n/t
vaberella
Jul 2013
#162
Nothing has changed. The U.S. has always been this way. What a sad situation. :(
tofuandbeer
Jul 2013
#17
It's almost as though people in authority positions can sense the end is near, and they're scared.
Kennah
Jul 2013
#19
Hope these poor cops aren't so traumatized they need an 8 month paid vacation & permanent disability
NBachers
Jul 2013
#20
Killing War Heroes who called accidentally hit 911, Shooting wheel chair guys armed with pencil
laserhaas
Jul 2013
#23
My point is what I posted. Since you're acting like you know more than anyone here, how's about
MADem
Jul 2013
#68
My brother used to do that work, and it is certainly difficult. He sometimes came home
MADem
Jul 2013
#113
I'm going to have to disagree with this, if those cops weren't such Nancy boys,
Snake Plissken
Jul 2013
#30
They were being "dicks", which is part of the description of "toxic masculinity".
SleeplessinSoCal
Jul 2013
#83
If you're debating the premise that many boys are raised to be dickish,
SleeplessinSoCal
Jul 2013
#122
Possibly you're not aware of this documentary that at it's heart is "toxic masculinity"
SleeplessinSoCal
Jul 2013
#142
I think I'd rather be stabbed by a 95 year old man trying to disarm him, than use a taser on him
Snake Plissken
Jul 2013
#27
Okay, cue the badge sniffers telling us it's only a select few bad apples
Nanjing to Seoul
Jul 2013
#28
#1. as said upthread, this is assisted living NOT A NURSING HOME. #2. I know someone who does
KittyWampus
Jul 2013
#36
"people freaking out can't be gently restrained" so you agreed with the taser use that killed her?
napoleon_in_rags
Jul 2013
#127
They are going to come up with a story that they thought that he was a danger to himself.
AnotherMcIntosh
Jul 2013
#54
The ambulance drivers thought he was a danger--that's why they called for the police.
MADem
Jul 2013
#144
The size of the knife also magically transformed from one with a 7" blade to a 12' butcher knife.
AnotherMcIntosh
Jul 2013
#58
Your anecdote is NOT evidence, and my thinking is not "muddled," thank you very much.
MADem
Jul 2013
#170
No, I do not--and flashing pictures of right wing hate mongers is a helluva way for you to make your
MADem
Aug 2013
#196
He's an American that is quite content with being ignorant, gullible and confused.
Lugal Zaggesi
Aug 2013
#197
No. I'm done with you. Go hang out with your ignorant, confused and gullible friend if you'd like.
MADem
Aug 2013
#198
was staying out of this one, but i was involved in a temporary detention order for a 92
loli phabay
Aug 2013
#184
Cowards. What can be more cowardly than shooting a 95-year old with beanbags?
AnotherMcIntosh
Jul 2013
#56
How did a cane and metal shoehorn suddenly change into a 12 inch butcher knife?
cstanleytech
Jul 2013
#59
Study should be done on exactly how and who are being hired as cops these days. Bet ya can trace it
glinda
Jul 2013
#79
Agreed. It is a leadership problem. A leadership problem where they view the populace as the enemy
AnotherMcIntosh
Jul 2013
#81