Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Latest Breaking News
In reply to the discussion: Former Pink Floyd frontman sparks fury by comparing Israelis to Nazis [View all]Jesus Malverde
(10,274 posts)112. He comes from an interesting family involved in the arms business.
His brother Bar-Kochba Botach runs bo-tach a arms supplier and his nephew Efraim Diveroli was convicted of selling bunk ammo to the US Military for use in the war in Afghanistan.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
275 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Former Pink Floyd frontman sparks fury by comparing Israelis to Nazis [View all]
dipsydoodle
Dec 2013
OP
nothing like blowing up a school bus or a nightclub to win your rebellion
Nanjing to Seoul
Dec 2013
#61
Please explain. You're comparing Nelson Mandela to Boko Harem and the Nazis
Nanjing to Seoul
Dec 2013
#115
Why? Because Arafat tried to overthrown the Jordanian and Lebanonese governments.
Nanjing to Seoul
Dec 2013
#116
What I dont get is the constant "blame Israel" chorus. No one ever criticizes the Arab countries.
7962
Dec 2013
#153
"If the Israelis wanted to, they could grab ALL the land. " They still may.
GoneFishin
Dec 2013
#234
Maps of the West Bank are starting to look a lot like those of the American West
KamaAina
Dec 2013
#241
I dont believe its ALL their fault; I mentioned the fact that Israel has their share of screw ups
7962
Dec 2013
#261
Oh, kinda like Israel not being on any Arab maps? You dont agree, so I'm telling "lies". Ha.
7962
Dec 2013
#257
Yes, thats exactly what I said(?). I dont know why I referenced them several times in my comments.
7962
Dec 2013
#263
They justified it with rampant nationalism, claiming God was with them and,....
Spitfire of ATJ
Dec 2013
#172
It's definitely a factor, but don't kid yourself in thinking it's the sole cause.
WatermelonRat
Dec 2013
#270
I actually prefer Gilmour's sad solo material to Water's sad solo material.
Enthusiast
Dec 2013
#151
No anti-semitism.. anti-Zionist... the new warmongers in the Middle East
DontTreadOnMe
Dec 2013
#147
Sorry, you don't to sneer at 'the Rabbis' and then claim it's mere anti-zionism. nt
geek tragedy
Dec 2013
#164
Related question. Is there any government other than Israel's that criticizing can lead to
DanTex
Dec 2013
#189
Criticizing Cuba or Venezuela will get you accused of being a neoliberal rightwinger.
geek tragedy
Dec 2013
#191
I see it like the Tea Party types who say Obama's policies will lead to/are worse than slavery.
geek tragedy
Dec 2013
#195
Quite True. Not to be confused with Spirituality, Organized Religion is specifically intended to
2banon
Dec 2013
#217
Actually, his ramblings about the "Jewish lobby" in the entertainment business is much more AS.
Behind the Aegis
Dec 2013
#50
Israel does "surgically" to Palestinians what the Nazis did to the Jewish people wholesale....
marble falls
Dec 2013
#11
Read him. But it will be difficult to get people here to even read his research and
kelliekat44
Dec 2013
#66
Did the pig also have a crescent with the star? They both abhor pork. Nazis didn't mind, though...
freshwest
Dec 2013
#16
Thanks. Pretty good reference of all the ideological, industrial and religious players.
freshwest
Dec 2013
#37
According to Nick Mason Roger Water's wrote that mainly with his new wife in mind.
dipsydoodle
Dec 2013
#146
" What was the Jewish body equivalent to Hamas that officially ruled the Warsaw Ghetto?"
Capt. Obvious
Dec 2013
#238
The answer is that there was no equivalent. The Nazis, not the Judenrat, were
geek tragedy
Dec 2013
#244
It actually shows just how much ant-semitism exists here on DU. It is outrageous
lostincalifornia
Dec 2013
#227
I've put a bunch of racists...er..."good progressives", on full ignore tonight.
abq e streeter
Dec 2013
#80
If only you could be as repulsed by the hateful shit offered by your fellows in I/P
Scootaloo
Dec 2013
#109
When people start using tropes out of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion
geek tragedy
Dec 2013
#170
Waters wasnt engaging in Stormfront rhetoric--just to clarify-was talking
geek tragedy
Dec 2013
#173
Supporting a great progressive like Roger Waters is now "Stormfront-style crap"
DisgustipatedinCA
Dec 2013
#186
No, but stating that "Wall Street money" is causing the US government to pledge
geek tragedy
Dec 2013
#188
I'm telling you why it could be considered the same thing, and really should be
Scootaloo
Dec 2013
#132
Or there is another explanation, but it would require self-reflection on your part.
Behind the Aegis
Dec 2013
#139
Or you're just really bad at explaining things. Seriously, consider the possibility
Scootaloo
Dec 2013
#143
I'm sure glad that Waters is allowed to use his right to free speech inasmush
R. Daneel Olivaw
Dec 2013
#96
ya cause we all just know Israel has never ever killed a Palestinian child well except for the 1373
azurnoir
Dec 2013
#120
Why not just quote the Protocols of the Elders of Zion while you're engaged in this crap?
geek tragedy
Dec 2013
#240
Ironically, those discriminated against within Israel's Jewish population
geek tragedy
Dec 2013
#245
Once again, you miss the whole point and just see "jews" as victims.
go west young man
Dec 2013
#252
I have posted the same thoughts; that I don't feel like I really belong on a site that allows
abq e streeter
Dec 2013
#174
naw, people love these posts so they can flame out. It has no constructive purpose, and does not
lostincalifornia
Dec 2013
#177
I hear you, which is why I expressed no useful purpose to threads of these types
lostincalifornia
Dec 2013
#203
"latest breaking news". A has been rocker gives an opinion? I don't think so....
lostincalifornia
Dec 2013
#176