Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

PoindexterOglethorpe

(28,485 posts)
33. I have a friend who's from western PA.
Wed May 31, 2017, 10:53 PM
May 2017

His name is Don, and sometimes when he calls me he announces himself as Dawn.

I try not to tease him too much.

I spent the first fourteen years of my life in upstate NY (Utica and nearby), then moved to Tucson, AZ. I joke that for the first two years there I had no friends because no one could understand me when I spoke, even my French teacher, no matter which language I used.

It was there that I first heard people pronounce pen and pin exactly the same.

The up side of moving to Tucson was that almost all of my NY accent was done away with in a couple of years. Every so often, but very rarely any more, someone with a good ear will correctly guess where I'm originally from.

I am fascinated by accents. I don't have a very good ear myself, and I'll confuse accents that are actually quite distinctive, but the entire topic of language, linguistics, accents, and the likes completely captivate me.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Pinnsylvania? Iggo May 2017 #1
my mother insists that mary, marry, and merry all sound different. unblock May 2017 #2
Marry sounds different. The other two are the same. brush May 2017 #27
We'll all be making merry when I marry Mary Mack. PoindexterOglethorpe May 2017 #32
Delightful to be sure. 3catwoman3 Jun 2017 #37
I absolutely love it. PoindexterOglethorpe Jun 2017 #40
Homonym HopeAgain May 2017 #3
doesn't apply to pin and pen Phentex May 2017 #6
Not homonyms. zanana1 Jun 2017 #65
Same here - totally different. smirkymonkey Jun 2017 #66
That's what I was saying... Phentex Jun 2017 #67
yes, regional differences demigoddess Jun 2017 #84
Some people in the south think set and sit sound the same... Phentex Jun 2017 #85
Homophones. eppur_se_muova Jun 2017 #73
exactly Phentex Jun 2017 #86
Nope. Homonyms. nt zanana1 Jun 2017 #88
The definitions I posted (courtesy of Google) say "both". nt eppur_se_muova Jun 2017 #90
It depends on your dialect. raging moderate May 2017 #4
Right, like there's a difference between Mme. Defarge May 2017 #5
You're from Western PA, Aren't You? Leith May 2017 #24
Portland, OR Mme. Defarge May 2017 #25
Never Mind Leith May 2017 #30
I have a friend who's from western PA. PoindexterOglethorpe May 2017 #33
I grew up out west, and pen and pin are pronounced differently Drahthaardogs Jun 2017 #72
I pronounce "caught" and "cot" the same. Dulcinea Jun 2017 #92
Larry the Cable Guy had a bit on this citood May 2017 #7
Classy zanana1 Jun 2017 #89
That's why there are inkpens C_U_L8R May 2017 #8
Pronouncing "winch" and "wench" the same can get you in trouble. alarimer May 2017 #9
You just brought back a small Army memory... jmowreader May 2017 #28
Important point. PoindexterOglethorpe May 2017 #34
And then some say wrinch when they mean wrench. Take a wrinch to that wench I say. yellowcanine Jun 2017 #76
Some people think "bury" and "berry" are pronounced differently. yellowcanine Jun 2017 #77
I picked some blueburries down by the crik. yellowcanine Jun 2017 #78
Pronounciation can be dangerous-- I once saw a guy almost get his ass kicked in a diner... TreasonousBastard May 2017 #10
In this case, "lazily" was probably correct, Spanish-wise! WinkyDink May 2017 #21
What dialect zipplewrath May 2017 #11
No difference Tiggeroshii May 2017 #12
What do you think of "cot" and "caught"? GBizzle May 2017 #13
Me too. Caught to me is said "cawt." Nt raccoon May 2017 #16
All the supposed homonyms mentioned in this thread sound different when I say them. Ron Obvious May 2017 #14
Totally different pronunciation. sinkingfeeling May 2017 #15
Yep, as alike as "covfefe" and "santorum" JustABozoOnThisBus May 2017 #17
Lol...pretty sure I interpreted that much dirtier than you intended.... Docreed2003 May 2017 #26
Both terms are wide open to interpretation. nt JustABozoOnThisBus Jun 2017 #45
It was the sounds alike part that got me...lol Docreed2003 Jun 2017 #47
The educated say "get", in Texas we say "git." LanternWaste May 2017 #18
Never mind ruining the Iambic Pentameter. ;-) WinkyDink May 2017 #22
my first week in Texas Skittles May 2017 #19
you found one that could write? bluecollar2 Jun 2017 #55
now now Skittles Jun 2017 #56
I know... bluecollar2 Jun 2017 #57
I do hear you Skittles Jun 2017 #60
Abbott bluecollar2 Jun 2017 #61
"Pin" is not pronounced as the writing utensil "pen." Not correctly, anyway. WinkyDink May 2017 #20
I don't hear a difference. Explain pls. brush May 2017 #31
Do you go... 3catwoman3 May 2017 #36
Sorry, still don't hear a difference. brush Jun 2017 #42
Me either. nt raccoon Jun 2017 #48
Ben went to the store. He found a good deal in the thrift shop bargain bin. MiltonBrown Jun 2017 #58
Must be genetic. nt raccoon Jun 2017 #62
Were you a terrible spiller in school? Did your teacher throw your book out the wendow? Phentex Jun 2017 #68
No, I never spilled anything. Lol nt raccoon Jun 2017 #69
Some math for you, Doc_Technical May 2017 #23
Um not around hear, I mean here........:) lunasun May 2017 #29
This thread is exactly why it's not remotely feasible to PoindexterOglethorpe May 2017 #35
I always thought it was odd when my grandmother would call Washington Warshington Doreen Jun 2017 #38
Ahhh. Again I first heard that pronunciation PoindexterOglethorpe Jun 2017 #39
oh I saw an episode on Matlock about that lol Was she from Arkansas? luvMIdog Jun 2017 #52
Pronounced correctly they are different rainy Jun 2017 #41
Still don't hear a difference. It's in the mind of the speaker I guess. brush Jun 2017 #43
try saying in then etch rainy Jun 2017 #44
Nah, any difference is in the mind of the speaker brush Jun 2017 #46
Wait; you seriously don't hear the difference Codeine Jun 2017 #50
OK -- how about flower and flour? NCjack Jun 2017 #53
living in ohio skippercollector Jun 2017 #49
Don Dawn- Con Yawn MiltonBrown Jun 2017 #59
What is your point? guillaumeb Jun 2017 #51
i make pin a little more nasaly.(is that a word?) samnsara Jun 2017 #54
"...I can't hear it." You can hear one of them drop. n/t retread Jun 2017 #63
What an interesting thread...thanks for starting it, raccoon. Glorfindel Jun 2017 #64
I definitely pronounce them differently ailsagirl Jun 2017 #70
My son came home from Georgia preschool one day with a new saying. aikoaiko Jun 2017 #71
If you think a pin is mightier than a sword IronLionZion Jun 2017 #74
How many angels can fit on the head of a pig pin? yellowcanine Jun 2017 #81
My Canadian husband greymattermom Jun 2017 #75
And some say that "roof" rhymes with "woof." But maybe they are spoofin. yellowcanine Jun 2017 #79
So do they pronounce penthouse as pinthouse? yellowcanine Jun 2017 #80
There does not seem to be a difference in hearing the sounds Phentex Jun 2017 #82
Witch and Which get a lot of people. yellowcanine Jun 2017 #83
A stickin' pin or a writin' pin? Brother Buzz Jun 2017 #87
Good friend of mine from GA would always differentiate by saying. NCTraveler Jun 2017 #91
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Some people seem to think...»Reply #33