Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

naaman fletcher

(7,362 posts)
8. in every case
Sat May 18, 2013, 02:09 PM
May 2013

where governments who don't know econ 101 and they cause shortages they ALWAYS blame hoarding.

Now, think this through a bit: What could this grocery store gain by hoarding? Remember, the stuff was in their warehouse so they paid for it.

They are out good money to just let products rot in their warehouse. To what end? OK, maybe they want to bring down the government. So they keep product in their warehouse. What happens then? People go to other stores and buy from there and they lose market share.

None of it makes sense.

What would happen in the US if Walmart did that? People would go to target. OK, maybe target wouldn't be prepared so there would be shortages for a few weeks as Target has to double it's orders from suppliers, but that's it. Just a few weeks. Meanwhile Walmart would have run itself out of business.

It doesn't make sense. It doesn't happen. It is basic economics.

The far more likely scenario is that these guys simply had a warehouse, and maduro needs someone to blame. Of course, Maduro just made a deal with Polar so a different scapegoat had to be found.

None of it makes sense if you know econ 101.


EDITED TO ADD: To be clear, hoarding can cause short run supply problems, but not long run. The hoarding causes prices to shoot up, causing producers to produce more which fixes the problem.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Supermarkets have warehouses naaman fletcher May 2013 #1
Wow, from obtuse denial to unsubstantiated ct woo, all in one post! Warren Stupidity May 2013 #2
I see, naaman fletcher May 2013 #3
Hey, you know what else causes shortages? ocpagu May 2013 #7
in every case naaman fletcher May 2013 #8
Yep, Polar had something to do with this. joshcryer May 2013 #28
Over 1000 tons of basic foods seized, 6000 kilos of chicken in downtown Maracaibo (Zulia), Catherina May 2013 #4
Very worth the time investigating. Since they won't consider their fellow Venezuelans, Judi Lynn May 2013 #5
Just like our multimillion dollar exploiters need some encouragement Catherina May 2013 #9
Maybe they should sell business and leave? Socialistlemur May 2013 #31
Video report of the confiscation in the 2 Enne stores. Manufactured "shortages" Catherina May 2013 #6
Stores which actually corner the market on essentials & don't deal fairly Judi Lynn May 2013 #10
I have to wonder - why would these distributors hoard? I can think of a few reasons. Flatulo May 2013 #11
Also, naaman fletcher May 2013 #12
No. If anything, they've demonstrated a staggering level of incompetence about all things monetary. Flatulo May 2013 #13
? ocpagu May 2013 #14
Well, in my relatively uneducated opinion, the government of VZ has taken a decidedly Marxist Flatulo May 2013 #15
Being so white, they are "incredibly industrious." Say, that's good news! Judi Lynn May 2013 #16
Fuck their skin color, look at their GDP! Flatulo May 2013 #18
Well, I'm familiar with Latin American private sector complaints... ocpagu May 2013 #17
Beautiful. We do know you know exactly what you're saying. Thanks. n/t Judi Lynn May 2013 #19
I'm not an advocate of laissez-faire capitalism, and the European social democracies Flatulo May 2013 #21
I think it's more the case that those who've relocated here are less risk-averse and thus less Flatulo May 2013 #22
Perhaps... ocpagu May 2013 #24
The adjusted GDP closely tracks the price of oil. It's not like they increased their productivity, Flatulo May 2013 #25
Oh, I almost forgot. ocpagu May 2013 #20
My initial impressions of Chavez were indeed shaped by mainstream media depictions, and Flatulo May 2013 #23
2 would make no sense for the company, of course. joshcryer May 2013 #29
I don't think the state is asking them to pay less. They're allowed to make a profit, but a fair one Catherina May 2013 #32
It's more than 20 items naaman fletcher May 2013 #33
Looks like it covers 616 items: joshcryer May 2013 #36
"The controlled price for toilet paper is $8.20(USD) for 12 rolls." naaman fletcher May 2013 #34
Is there any genuine competition in the retail Flatulo May 2013 #48
k/r Dawson Leery May 2013 #26
Hang a few CEOs mwrguy May 2013 #27
Do you work to just break even? If I pay for your gas and Flatulo May 2013 #30
They can still make a profit. Catherina May 2013 #37
I'm glad you agree that a reasonable profit is not a bad thing. People need some incentive Flatulo May 2013 #39
The problems is the different definitions of reasonable Catherina May 2013 #41
"400% ? That's price-gouging" naaman fletcher May 2013 #42
I more or less agree with you on executive compensation and corporate governance. Flatulo May 2013 #43
FWIW naaman fletcher May 2013 #44
Abso-fucking-lutely. Flatulo May 2013 #45
Why do we need stock portfolios? What's wrong with good old-fashioned pension plans? Catherina May 2013 #46
Pension plans are great, if you can find them anymore in the private sector. Of course, the Flatulo May 2013 #47
Canada has the right idea on medicine. Most of their medicines are under price controls Catherina May 2013 #35
Yes, shelter and water as well mwrguy May 2013 #38
Manufacturing drugs is relatively straightforward. It's the massive R&D that goes into bringing Flatulo May 2013 #40
Latest Discussions»Region Forums»Latin America»4 Board Members of Enne S...»Reply #8