Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(37,952 posts)
13. Tell us how you really feel. This sort of thing goes back to the days of David Brower.
Mon Dec 13, 2021, 09:18 PM
Dec 2021

He "traded" Glen Canyon for the Grand Canyon in the 1960s.

He didn't own Glen Canyon - it belonged to humanity, and of course, the creatures that lived there - but he felt fine trading it nevertheless.

And then there's John Muir and the Hetch Hetchy, another battle lost.

And yes, there was a proposal to turn the Grand Canyon into another Lake Powell. I'm glad we saved the Grand Canyon, but...but...but...

Now of course, today the Colorado River is not merely wounded; it's dying. The reason is climate change. One reason for climate change is all the years wasted on a reactionary effort to return to so called "renewable energy," centuries after humanity abandoned it for a reason. It wasted time; it wasted money; and much destruction resulted.

I can't say I entirely fault President Biden for this state of affairs. In the 19 years I've been writing here, among my fellow Democrats there's been a great deal of enthusiasm for mining coal just so long as the coal goes into making steel for wind turbine posts. I don't see how President Biden could say that he opposes wind energy.

I'm fine saying it; I'm not sure he could.

Wind power, and for that matter, solar power, is the Ivermectin of climate change.

There has been visceral hatred of nuclear energy on the left; our answer, on the left, to creationism on their side, the right, and of course, now, their loony anti-vax movement that really reminds me of the anti-nuclear movement.

Now I see dunderhead anti-nukes trying to tell me they're not anti-nukes. They apparently think I'm as stupid as they have been for decades.

There's very little Schadenfreude here on my part; the future of my family is every bit as threatened as anyone else's. What has happened already is a tragedy, to be sure.

This said, some of the basic research for the so called "renewable energy" industry is not a total waste, and can be modified to fit less stupid approaches. This is particularly true of thermal solar nonsense. I often feel when reading those papers that the authors stuck "solar thermal" on the title to get grants.

I do hope we can see clearly before killing off desert tortoises and the like, trashing Nevada. I agree. It's a beautiful State, worthy of preservation.

I can see, even here, in "Renewables will save us" fantasy land, a change taking place.

The President's nuclear policy is rather enlightened I think. It looks like he's going to join the fight to save Diablo Canyon, although at this point, it's a long shot.

Frankly Biden's policies are a damned sight better than Obama's. Obama started off strong by hiring Steven Chu, but ended up, at the behest of Markey, appointing the complete idiot Gregory Jaczko to the NRC. Jaczko, like all anti-nukes doesn't give a shit how many tens and hundreds of millions of people die from air pollution if he can imagine in his trivializing little head that someone somewhere might die from radiation.

This week I loaned my son Alvin Weinberg's The First Nuclear Era. What's going on in our national labs today reminds me very much of those times. The reactors being built are not the ones I might have designed, but they all show creativity and open minds. The happiest thing for me is to see is the dream of Seikimoto's "Candle" reactors reaching commercialization. I attribute this state of affairs to President Biden's good will.

There's an outside chance the world will be saved, something of a long shot, but a chance. If it is saved, nuclear engineers will save it.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I have to go with all the automakers who have thought of all that and still they Alexander Of Assyria Dec 2021 #1
Maybe I read a bit more than you do. n/t. NNadir Dec 2021 #2
Maybe, impossible to tell. Dense chemical science journals, I'll give you that. Alexander Of Assyria Dec 2021 #3
Ha! Eko Dec 2021 #5
More strawman. Eko Dec 2021 #4
I obviously get around more than some people. NNadir Dec 2021 #6
Its sloppy rhetoric to have a strawman in your title. Eko Dec 2021 #7
It's lying to post photoshopped pictures of mutants as if they... NNadir Dec 2021 #8
Of course the title stands, you're the king of strawman on here. Eko Dec 2021 #9
Thank you for sharing your opinion. I'm quite sure you think highly of it. NNadir Dec 2021 #10
You're welcome. Eko Dec 2021 #11
Nevada will be a solar farm and utility lines and roads and lithium mine waste dump very soon. jeffreyi Dec 2021 #12
Tell us how you really feel. This sort of thing goes back to the days of David Brower. NNadir Dec 2021 #13
Nuclear engineers will contribute to saving the planet, yes. Fusion and all things Alexander Of Assyria Dec 2021 #15
There is no reason to use solar energy for any purpose except in certain cases in remote systems. NNadir Dec 2021 #16
When someone can put a nuclear engine in a car or in a house, call me. Alexander Of Assyria Dec 2021 #18
Lots of factual errors. Start with lithium batteries can't be recycled... Alexander Of Assyria Dec 2021 #14
There are thousands of papers in the primary scientific literature on the issues in recycling... NNadir Dec 2021 #17
Car cultists...glib nonsense...wishful thinking...marketing hype...that's a lot of strawmen to Alexander Of Assyria Dec 2021 #19
I call it as I see it. For more than half a century I've listened to.... NNadir Dec 2021 #20
There's a company in Scottsburg Indiana that recycles the main battery on a Prius Finishline42 Dec 2021 #21
Really? Problem solved then? I guess the authors of this paper are nowhere near as wise... NNadir Dec 2021 #22
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»Of course, we're all goin...»Reply #13