Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(37,970 posts)
11. And? Is this supposed to be a big deal? They're still burning coal, the waste of which...
Wed Jan 19, 2022, 07:24 PM
Jan 2022

...kills people. Germany is burning a fuel that kills people, millions upon millions, because they have announced that nuclear energy, which has a spectacular record of killing very few people over more than half a century, is in their mind "too dangerous."

Really? This kind of antisense is of the sort that could drivel out the mouth of a Republican. It's as stupid as anything Trump has said, and Trump is famously stupid.

The problem with so called "renewable energy" is that it's random.

If has to be proud of 233 g CO2/kwh (as of this writing , 6:06 PM EST US, Germany is now at 255 g CO2/kwh), one is clueless. Climate change is real. Germany has been on this path of ignorance celebration for 20 years.

The Germans have not once, yet, in any time I've checked, not been less than 200%, in the "percent talk" apologists for this disaster so love to use, worse than France. Right now, in percent talk, the German contempt for future generations and for climate change is 263% higher than that of France, where the carbon intensity is 97 g CO2/kwh.

I note that France is not doing as well as it would have been doing if, instead of building wind turbines that will be landfill in less than 25 years, they had used the money to build a nuclear plant. As a result of building wind crap, the French now have to burn dangerous natural gas. As of this writing, 11.26% of French generated electricity - some of which they are exporting to that coal burning hellhole Germany (524 MW) to lower the abysmal German climate performance - is generated by burning dangerous natural gas and dumping the waste directly into the planetary atmosphere. Although it is responsible for a small fraction of French electricity, it accounts for 56.94% of the dangerous fossil fuel waste France is dumping because they didn't build a nuclear plant instead of wind junk. That is the environmental cost of "investing" in wind.

Replace the 8.08 GW of dangerous natural gas now being burned in France, and it's carbon intensity falls. 0.1126 * (490 - 12) g CO2/kwh represents 53 g CO2 being added to France's tally because they drank the wind energy Kool-Aid and thus have to burn gas.

If I am indeed being asked to cheer for this tragedy, it is immediately clear to me that people suggesting I do think I'm some kind of idiot. I note that anti-nukes, including the most egregious members of that class, the "I'm not an anti-nuke" anti-nukes generally assume I'm an idiot by offering up such nonsense and expecting it to be taken seriously.

I don't think cheering is appropriate. I think all it calls from me is contempt.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

It is freezing 37 F tonight in NW Florida at140 Jan 2022 #1
Interesting to find at the Electricity Map link in your OP Finishline42 Jan 2022 #2
It's trivial amounts of power, and I note, responsible for disproportionate emissions. NNadir Jan 2022 #3
As of now, 11:00 AM US EST 01/18/22, Germany's... NNadir Jan 2022 #4
French nuclear John ONeill Jan 2022 #7
And at 3pm in Calif Finishline42 Jan 2022 #5
Oh goody. Percent talk from a five minute interval. You know, if one gives a shit, one can... NNadir Jan 2022 #6
A couple of things about Calif Finishline42 Jan 2022 #10
California Energy Regulations, according to PG&E CEO -- progree Jan 2022 #13
Californian renewables John ONeill Jan 2022 #8
Germany on Jan 19 at 3pm Finishline42 Jan 2022 #9
And? Is this supposed to be a big deal? They're still burning coal, the waste of which... NNadir Jan 2022 #11
Germany last year Finishline42 Jan 2022 #12
I decided to cherry pick a time to respond to this silliness. Right now, in "percent talk" German... NNadir Jan 2022 #14
As of today, in "percent talk" German Electricity CO2 Intensity is 510% higher than that of France. NNadir Jan 2022 #15
This morning's cherry pick in percent talk: Germany is producing 233% more electricity from coal... NNadir Jan 2022 #16
It isn't looking any prettier this afternoon, at 501 g CO2/kwh in Germany. NNadir Jan 2022 #17
From your link - Germany today at 6pm is at 153g Carbon Intensity Finishline42 Feb 2022 #18
Yeah, this is the first time they've been under 200% worse than France in weeks. NNadir Feb 2022 #19
And now come the Nord Stream 2 troubles, sooner than expected... hunter Feb 2022 #20
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»At this hour, German elec...»Reply #11