Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

aranthus

(3,385 posts)
22. I figured you wouldn't answer the question, but I wanted to give you a chance.
Tue Mar 10, 2020, 01:25 PM
Mar 2020

You know your posts far better than I could, and I'm not going to waste my time searching through them for something that probably isn't there. I asked a very specific question that I don't remember you ever having answered. What is the practical difference between your version of post-zionism and anti-zionism? Your cite doesn't answer that question. It does point out one of the problems with post-zionism. Post-zionism falsely describes zionism as a movement. While there is a Zionist movement, zionism is an idea. Specifically it is the idea that there should be a Jewish majority state in all or some of ancient Israel. Now the creation of modern Israel may mean that the Zionist movement has achieved its goal, but the idea remains. So the premise of post-zionism is false.

None of which even begins to answer my question as to your position about the end result of your beliefs. Again, it appears that your end result is a Palestinian Arab majority state in Israel/West Bank/Gaza. Yes or no?

Benny Morris....... Israeli Mar 2020 #1
So what? aranthus Mar 2020 #2
Oh I dont like him at all ..... Israeli Mar 2020 #3
Jeremy Hammond sabbat hunter Mar 2020 #4
Does he ? Israeli Mar 2020 #5
From his own website sabbat hunter Mar 2020 #6
I read it ..... Israeli Mar 2020 #11
Waiting to see who howls first because its written by an Arab Israeli Mar 2020 #12
I believe that sabbat hunter Mar 2020 #15
Maybe sooner than you think ...... Israeli Mar 2020 #18
What is the Balad faction? sabbat hunter Mar 2020 #25
Seriously .... Israeli Mar 2020 #26
I would love to see Joint List in the government. aranthus Mar 2020 #16
He's just another lying Leftist antisemite. aranthus Mar 2020 #7
Oh please ..... Israeli Mar 2020 #9
Be honest. aranthus Mar 2020 #14
I was actually reffering to this : Israeli Mar 2020 #19
As to Bernie. aranthus Mar 2020 #23
Again so what? aranthus Mar 2020 #8
Nope ..... Israeli Mar 2020 #10
Again, so what? aranthus Mar 2020 #13
You didnt answer my question .... Israeli Mar 2020 #20
Another question. aranthus Mar 2020 #17
I have been thru all this .... Israeli Mar 2020 #21
I figured you wouldn't answer the question, but I wanted to give you a chance. aranthus Mar 2020 #22
And I figured you would not answer mine Israeli Mar 2020 #24
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Israel/Palestine»In Bay Area, candid Israe...»Reply #22