Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Gun Control & RKBA

Showing Original Post only (View all)
 

TPaine7

(4,286 posts)
Sat Apr 21, 2012, 06:48 PM Apr 2012

"Judge, Jury and Executioner" [View all]

Put yourself in the position of a wheelchair-bound young man who lives with his mother. You work online and you make a pretty good living as a programmer. You live in a remote area, and you love the natural beauty, but police response times can be very long under the best of circumstances.

Dad is dead, and your siblings have moved away. But before dad died, he insisted that you learn to use a gun. He was adamant that you be very proficient, in spite of your hatred for guns, and eventually you became a crack shot.

Dad believed that you might need skill with a weapon someday, and while on his deathbed he made you swear to keep up your skills, keep a gun accessible whenever legal and keep a CCW permit if at all possible.

So when the local serial rapist, torturer and killer of women breaks in, you have a hidden gun nearby.

Thinking you are helpless, he calmly stands over your trembling mother, detailing his exploits with the poor women you have heard about on the news. He says your mom, while older than most of his conquests, is still pretty good looking, and he praises her physical assets. He says this will be the first time he's had an audience, and that that will make it especially fun. And after the show, you'll get to be the first man he's killed. He says you should be honored.

At this, you pull out your gun, prepared to use it just like dad taught you. He's momentarily shocked, but then recovers. "I don't think you have it in you," he sneers as he reaches down for Mom.

So what do you do? Do you reach for the phone and hope mom survives the next 30 - 45 minutes until the cops arrive or do you act as "judge, jury and executioner"?

57 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
"Judge, Jury and Executioner" [View all] TPaine7 Apr 2012 OP
Nice Fairy Tale jpak Apr 2012 #1
Denying realities that you don't like doesn't make them less real. TPaine7 Apr 2012 #2
Or shooting it into safer one either. orpupilofnature57 Apr 2012 #4
So shooting the man in my scenario WOULD NOT make the world—and especially your corner of it—safer?! TPaine7 Apr 2012 #7
Sure it would ,how often is your scenario orpupilofnature57 Apr 2012 #26
Probably once or never in the history of the world. TPaine7 Apr 2012 #32
You made up your fantasy - it is not "real" jpak Apr 2012 #6
The capacity for abstract thought is vital. Yes I made this exact scenario up. TPaine7 Apr 2012 #10
Thank you for sharing your Mommy Rape Big Gun Hero Fantasy jpak Apr 2012 #17
Why don't you shed a little light on the anti gun culture crowd. WHAT WOULD YOU DO? TPaine7 Apr 2012 #19
I would shut off that stupid TV movie - and have a sandwich. jpak Apr 2012 #20
Evasion is all you have when your position is untenable. I understand why you can't answer, jpak. nt TPaine7 Apr 2012 #27
Denying realities... discntnt_irny_srcsm Apr 2012 #36
Much better tale... Clames Apr 2012 #16
And not even a very good one COLGATE4 Apr 2012 #41
Something similar actually happened to a DUer. GreenStormCloud Apr 2012 #57
Like a son with a gun on a creep ,that orpupilofnature57 Apr 2012 #3
So low probability events are MOOT? (Not mute.) TPaine7 Apr 2012 #9
Thanks for spelling Moot , but orpupilofnature57 Apr 2012 #29
Low probability =| cartoon as I am sure people who have TPaine7 Apr 2012 #31
Because it's fun to shit on guns ,and orpupilofnature57 Apr 2012 #30
re: "...shooting defensively in the home is a low probability event..." discntnt_irny_srcsm Apr 2012 #38
You carry a panic button, and a loud siren blares. depending on whether the freak has a weapon, WingDinger Apr 2012 #5
He's already called your "bluff" so telling him to FREEZE is pointless. n/t TPaine7 Apr 2012 #14
OK, you have a dog, a tazer, a pepper spray canister. ? When you are home invaded, only a dog will WingDinger Apr 2012 #21
???? TPaine7 Apr 2012 #22
Home invasions are rarely one person. They stake out the property, then insure the element of surpri WingDinger Apr 2012 #23
I think you're misinformed, and you cite only your imagination. TPaine7 Apr 2012 #24
Don't think I missed your evasion of my earlier point. TPaine7 Apr 2012 #25
Yelling "Freeze Mf'er" would be useless unless you escalate shadowrider Apr 2012 #42
"Unless you sleep with your gun at hand, you WILL.......... Simo 1939_1940 Apr 2012 #28
Easy answer, You kill him to stop him from raping your mother. Any sane person would. n-t Logical Apr 2012 #8
Then there are a lot of insane (or dishonest) antis, TPaine7 Apr 2012 #11
I agree. These people obviously never have spent 5 minutes thinking of how bad.... Logical Apr 2012 #18
Myself he would have been dead the moment he entered my home and wouldn't doc03 Apr 2012 #12
Simple atreides1 Apr 2012 #13
I act as J, J & E. NT Simo 1939_1940 Apr 2012 #15
Never be rude to society...better to see your mom raped, tortured and murdered. ileus Apr 2012 #33
No , appoint yourself God orpupilofnature57 Apr 2012 #34
So you would appoint yourself God?!!! TPaine7 Apr 2012 #35
Yes , I've always have loved mom , and would orpupilofnature57 Apr 2012 #39
"Knowing people are silly and constantly posing situations , that put them in a situation where TPaine7 Apr 2012 #43
Gotta say , Valid points orpupilofnature57 Apr 2012 #44
I am in awe of your honesty. Kudos. n/t TPaine7 Apr 2012 #45
My Jeep is god...I could never take it's place. ileus Apr 2012 #37
Now some meme will tell orpupilofnature57 Apr 2012 #40
How often - per day, week, or month - do you imagine yourself in that position? Hoyt Apr 2012 #46
The OP was the first and only time. I made it up to see how completely people like you believe in TPaine7 Apr 2012 #47
I'd get some big friggin dogs, and quit living in fear of something rare. Hoyt Apr 2012 #48
Yeah, about what I expected. I understand, Hoyt. Really, I do. n/t TPaine7 Apr 2012 #49
Just because guns are always the easy solution for you, hardly makes it good for society. Hoyt Apr 2012 #50
Guns are rarely the solution. Very rarely. TPaine7 Apr 2012 #51
I will never be in that situation. And the one guy who might in the next Hoyt Apr 2012 #52
There might only be one guy who hates guns, makes his living as a programmer and who is threatened TPaine7 Apr 2012 #53
Why don't you try a rational, intelligent question? Hoyt Apr 2012 #54
LOL! That's right Hoyt; if you cover your eyes, we can't see you... TPaine7 Apr 2012 #55
Why don't you try a rational, intelligent question? AH1Apache Apr 2012 #56
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Gun Control & RKBA»"Judge, Jury and Exe...»Reply #0