Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
African American
In reply to the discussion: I only get into trouble on DU when I try to get to what's real. [View all]1StrongBlackMan
(31,849 posts)287. I had to read this three times to be certain you were saying what I thought I read ...
And, it appears that I read it correctly the first time; so forgive me if this comes across as an attack ... Are you insane?
If the New Deal and the Great Society legislation and regulations had remained intact, and the work that unions had been fighting and dying for since the late 1800s not been wiped away, and all the work of 100 years by progressives not been reversed by "centrist", Third Way, republican/Democrats over the past 25 years, progressives might be more receptive to the voting demographic that elected the politicians who caused it.
First, the New Deal and the Great Society legislation and regulations remain intact, and the work that unions had been fighting and dying for since the late 1800s has not been wiped away ... and fuck you, if you think you can lay the recent and current attempts to roll back the gains of the early 20th century at the feet of the Black electorate, if that's what you meant by, "the voting demographic that elected the politicians who caused it."
Yes, Black voters came out, in force, for Bill Clinton ... and so did better than half the Democratic Party, because we, all, made the electability calculation. Do you really believe the progressive darling, Jerry Brown could have beat the incumbent President, Pappy Bush? While Brown had the better platform of all the candidates in the field, Democratic or republican, the American electorate turns very, very slowly. And, after nearly 20 years of republican administrations (with a brief respite during the Carter years), a Brown Presidency was considered a race, too far ... disappointing; but, a reasonable calculation based on historical electoral politics.
Progressives, in one form or another have been fighting for black lives since black people were livestock. Progressives have been fighting to improve the quality of black lives since reconstruction. Progressives have been sacrificing their lives, metaphorically and literally since before this country existed.
We've fought a lot of fights that benefited a lot of people.
We've fought a lot of fights that benefited a lot of people.
I really don't understand this chest beating and self-back slapping ... first, do you want a rhetorical cookie for doing what the left, hell ... human beings, are supposed to do? And/but more, what does that history have to do with the current "less receptiveness" towards Black Lives, now?
Make no mistake, the driving force behind BLM is, as you mention, the heart-breaking voicelessness on issues that are paramount to them/us; so, it is/was no coincidence that BLM chose the progressive forum of NRN to be heard. In my estimation, there is no better example of the promotion of that voicelessness, than Bernie's economic primacy message (sorry O'Malley, he just got caught in the cross-fire, as his campaign message is far more balanced between economic and racial interests).
If you, progressives, think Black folks should/would sit still for discussions about your purse (or, even, our purses) while we are, literally, dying in the streets, because you put, in your estimation, in enough time on the issue, you can kiss my Black ass.
When I say that, I'm not asking for thanks or for any special favor. The good that was done is gone. There is nothing left to thank previous generations for. The scars my 90 year old grandfather still has from the beatings the cops and the union busters gave him for his effort to establish worker protections were wasted. There's no more 40 hour work week, or 8 hour day, and soon, no more unions at all.
That is a bunch of facile bull shit, conspiratorial facile bullshit, at that. The decline in union membership is more traceable to unions' becoming the monster that they were born to fight AND a generation (or more) of narcissistic workers. There is NOTHING that stops workers from organizing beyond a generalized disinterest in doing the work to do so. The mechanisms and protections remain in place ... it is no more, or less difficult to organize a workplace, today, than it was in 1980. But/and, organizing is far easier today, than it was in the immediate years after union membership peaked in 1954.
But that said ... As unions grew in numbers and, therefore, influence, they became (or, were/are perceived as) hierarchical, bureaucratized, top down organizations, that lost touch with its rank and file ... which is not unusual for movements shortly after their reaching a critical mass; it happened/is happening in the (Black) Civil Rights Movement, the Feminist Movement, the LGBT Movement, La Raza Movement, etc., even as these movements continue.
Couple that with a generation (or more) of workers that buy into the immediate gratification of Meism, that have little connection to "the struggle", as they were born into its benefits. It is of no wonder that (just as with the Black Civil Rights movement) the current beneficiaries are less engaged.
The fate of the American system of government (such as it is), is not actually the most pressing matter, neither is the fate of any demographic of America's citizens.
The next election will decide the the fate of the air we breath, the water we drink, and the food we eat. The next election will decide who lives and dies on a global scale. It will be unlike anything seen in human history. It will rival an ice age in its destruction.
Oh, yeah, there's gonna be an ice age. That's on the centrists too. We told you so.
The next election will decide the the fate of the air we breath, the water we drink, and the food we eat. The next election will decide who lives and dies on a global scale. It will be unlike anything seen in human history. It will rival an ice age in its destruction.
Oh, yeah, there's gonna be an ice age. That's on the centrists too. We told you so.
I, largely, agree here, though I see little space between the Democratic candidates on addressing climate change.
No. I, actually, don't think you are insane ... but, rather a/the product of being at the political extreme that benefits from being on the outside yelling at those that actually get things done; albeit, slowly and through pragmatic compromise.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
349 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
There is so much ignorance and passive aggression in this post, I don't know where to begin
Number23
Jul 2015
#171
I noticed this person never came back to this thread but got a ping that she posted something damn
Number23
Jul 2015
#346
I am so sick of people misappropriating Dr. King's legacy & bastardizing his words. Not cool.
Tarheel_Dem
Jul 2015
#217
It is a deliberately cynical attempt to rewrite history. I hate it when Republicans do it, and I...
Tarheel_Dem
Jul 2015
#276
If one can't run on one's record, then what else is there? He has ideas that sound good to me...
1monster
Jul 2015
#233
My group? I visit the Bernie group when it hits the front page. I don't spend a lot of time
1monster
Jul 2015
#245
I bet face to face we would be able to find common ground without the exasperation.
bravenak
Jul 2015
#248
I have worked on plenty of campaigns where volunteers were rejected or fired ...
1StrongBlackMan
Jul 2015
#110
I agree that we need a healthy discussion. Having "safe" areas is a mistake since it seems
Dustlawyer
Jul 2015
#15
Noooo---I think "the black community" needs to educate the "Bernie supporter community"--not the
MADem
Jul 2015
#103
I felt the same way when I read that. BERNIE and the rest of them need educating, not us
Number23
Jul 2015
#172
I am a bit surprised at the amount of likely unaware, or unintentional, or dare I say
MADem
Jul 2015
#193
I'm coming in late to this thread but it is so good and I wanted to chime in, mainly to wrap
Chiquitita
Jul 2015
#348
Exactly, MADem.. As If.. the Black Community needs "educating" by bernie supporters..
Cha
Jul 2015
#304
I was banned from a Hillary group. If you can't defend your position, the easiest thing to do,
Hoppy
Jul 2015
#4
I was notified I was banned from the Hillary group, even though I hadn't posted a single thing there
HFRN
Jul 2015
#29
It's a false statement. Hosts can only block a person by clicking a link on the post they made IN
MADem
Jul 2015
#108
Oh come on ... he/she said he/she was NOTIFIED that he/she was banned from the Hillary group ...
1StrongBlackMan
Jul 2015
#113
I don't think you can do that - at least in AfAm we don't have that ability
JustAnotherGen
Jul 2015
#87
No host has that ability. They must post first, exactly as MADem said. Skinner said so in ATA. So...
freshwest
Jul 2015
#322
when i received the notification, i searched theough 'My Posts' to find a post in that forum
HFRN
Jul 2015
#105
It is a physical impossibility to get banned from a group you haven't posted in.
MADem
Jul 2015
#107
Then post the notification and prove, what many, including me, thinks is a lie.
1StrongBlackMan
Jul 2015
#118
It's something for your resume that you made a false claim and then when it's disproved you try
Cha
Jul 2015
#215
Aha.. the proof from July 9, 2015.. We all knew you can't be blocked from a group without
Cha
Jul 2015
#158
Got a question - have you tried contacting the Host that blocked you and discussing it?
azurnoir
Jul 2015
#5
Why?? Progressives are frustrated that they don't gain ground, in spite of economic inequality
lostnfound
Jul 2015
#23
Since you are posting here, I assume that it is because you wish to hear an answer ...
1StrongBlackMan
Jul 2015
#30
I had to read this three times to be certain you were saying what I thought I read ...
1StrongBlackMan
Jul 2015
#287
Thank Baby Jesus! Where are they coming from, or are these "return performances" if you know what..
Tarheel_Dem
Jul 2015
#331
That actually breaks down close to the beginning because the progressive candidate isn't mostly the
TheKentuckian
Jul 2015
#333
Before I respond ... Please define/describe "New Left Activist". Thanks.
1StrongBlackMan
Jul 2015
#72
It should bloody well be able to be brought up in the Sanders group.
Erich Bloodaxe BSN
Jul 2015
#16
And my point is that I want the Sanders group to be BETTER than 'anoy other candidate safe haven'.
Erich Bloodaxe BSN
Jul 2015
#21
Here's a guess... it may be because NO OTHER GROUP ON DU is as hostile to black Americans now than
Number23
Jul 2015
#176
O'malley screwed up at Netroots too. The only difference is that his SUPPORTERS were not out on the
Number23
Jul 2015
#180
So that's your answer? The reason more stupidity, more callousness and more RACISM has come
Number23
Jul 2015
#216
Well, I edited. I din't want it to look like I was talking about somebody that couldn't talk back
Number23
Jul 2015
#274
"know that supporters of Sanders are open to legitimate criticism especially on the whole with
Cha
Jul 2015
#159
If you were a black person who said that black people need some self-examination, not ONE person
Number23
Jul 2015
#169
That is my problem with him. Certainly. Only comes back here to chastise us but won't tell his
bravenak
Jul 2015
#182
I'm just gonna do it to make sure he does not come in here to chastise black folks.
bravenak
Jul 2015
#194
Well, it's pretty clear who he is now. So that makes it pretty clear who his friends are too.
Number23
Jul 2015
#197
I come across Sanders supporters EVERY DAY that won't post in the Sanders group
Number23
Jul 2015
#179
I am white and I support Bernie Sanders about 95%. I also some problems when....
marble falls
Jul 2015
#40
You were there and I watched the tapes and my wife and I were and are surprised how few...
marble falls
Jul 2015
#48
Nice try. Are you saying African Americans have evolved their opinion in the last month and ....
marble falls
Jul 2015
#84
AA voters are not stupid but no, we are not more informed than any other group
Number23
Jul 2015
#220
You wouldn't think that poster could possibly be anymore insulting.. but, I wouldn't bet on it.
Cha
Jul 2015
#303
I've seen enough. Between your performance in this thread and your idiotic performance a few months
Number23
Jul 2015
#184
Like I said, the fact that you focused so much on that one word while ignoring their point
Number23
Jul 2015
#208
As a Sandernista myself, I agree with you and don't get the disconnect between Bernie's....
marble falls
Jul 2015
#85
No, some of Bernie's supporters are swiftboating Bernie, by acting like privileged idiots.
MADem
Jul 2015
#106
May I just AMEN to everything you just uttered? You just took me to church.
Tarheel_Dem
Jul 2015
#243
Just as you wish to have to avoid much flack being hurled in this protected group
Autumn
Jul 2015
#65
Come on--I welcomed Bernie to the primary, said straight up he was my 2nd choice,
MADem
Jul 2015
#168
I will tell ya, the way some of his (cough) supporters (cough) are talking, it's making me
MADem
Jul 2015
#102
Don't forget that Obama was playing Rope-A-Dope with Republicans around that time
Warpy
Jul 2015
#251
Not only "I'm not a liberal", but "I've never been a liberal". And you're right, people "overlay"..
Tarheel_Dem
Jul 2015
#283
"The most popular politician among African-Americans is Bill Clinton." Really? Link?
Tarheel_Dem
Jul 2015
#250
No, you are not the only Bernie supporter who has been blocked from the BS Group, Tobin..
Cha
Jul 2015
#162
I remember your posts in this group and in previous iterations of the AA forum.
Number23
Jul 2015
#196
He also whipped out a chart showing how blacks don't like Jews. Had it right at his fingertips.
Tarheel_Dem
Jul 2015
#310