Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Religion

In reply to the discussion: What is prayer? [View all]
 

durbin

(73 posts)
5. No, surprisingly, we never discussed the act(s) of prayer, I respected their
Fri Jun 14, 2013, 04:13 PM
Jun 2013

decisions and their activities, whatever day of the week, whatever time of day.

I never intruded with my "curious" nature upon their acts of prayer, which were usually done outside of my viewing, by the way.

I respect people with sincere religious beliefs, but I would never ask about their prayers in person. The internet seems to be the best place for anonymous discussion of this topic, honestly.

And, by the way, my questions here, have more to do with the nature of what is prayer, something practiced by dozens of religions for the last few thousand years, why the curiosity about my past over the last 50+ years? I went some nice places, met some nice religious and non-religious, non-Chrisitian, non Jewish, non Muslim non anything people, and yet you're curious about my life and not willing to venture into an answer to my questions; questions any religiously trained American should have answers to, I assume, (having been born out of the USA, but a US citizen by birth, 50+ years ago, I had two American parents, not religious, but Americans from birth).


By the way, it seems you are very wary of my questions, and unwilling to answer, but want to question me more?

Why? Maybe prayer that hard to talk about for many believers.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

What is prayer? [View all] durbin Jun 2013 OP
While you say you don't have answers, what are your thoughts about these questions? cbayer Jun 2013 #1
No who hasn't thought about prayer in the USA? We all have heard about it or done it. durbin Jun 2013 #2
Wait, I'm confused. Aren't you the fellow who just wrote a long post cbayer Jun 2013 #3
No, surprisingly, we never discussed the act(s) of prayer, I respected their durbin Jun 2013 #5
If asked sincerely, I don't think religious people would have any problem discussing cbayer Jun 2013 #10
Assuming prayer is communication, the best analogy is how we communicate with each other. rug Jun 2013 #4
Thanks, will study. durbin Jun 2013 #6
There's a lot to be said about prayer that isn't a true/false answer. rug Jun 2013 #9
There's a remarkable amount of prayer available for your computer, but almost all Buddhist. dimbear Jun 2013 #7
Buddhist prayer centers, I lived next door to one for a summer durbin Jun 2013 #8
As this thread seems to offend people who pray, I will durbin Jun 2013 #11
Offends people that pray? Where do you get that idea? cbayer Jun 2013 #14
Most posts like this are not really questions, but attempts to draw people in and then mock them. goldent Jun 2013 #29
I was just thinking about... Mike Nelson Jun 2013 #12
I thought it was an interesting discussion... Mike Nelson Jun 2013 #13
Agreed, I thought that the concept of prayer was very worthy of durbin Jun 2013 #16
My thought is that you... Mike Nelson Jun 2013 #21
I wanted a red bike and got one at 10 years old. durbin Jun 2013 #24
People on DU often ask for "good vibes" and sometimes ask for prayers. cbayer Jun 2013 #15
Thinking good thoughts... Mike Nelson Jun 2013 #18
Agree, I don't care much what people call it and I don't think it is always asking cbayer Jun 2013 #20
Agree - nt Mike Nelson Jun 2013 #22
Is that what prayer is? Is that all prayer is? durbin Jun 2013 #23
Ancient New-Age, Self-Help Meditation NoOneMan Jun 2013 #17
Can you be more specific, or give links? durbin Jun 2013 #19
Self-affirmation, self-reassurance, etc NoOneMan Jun 2013 #27
my wish list given to a magic sky guy. rurallib Jun 2013 #25
liturgical christians have a tradition of both meditation and prayer. nt xchrom Jun 2013 #26
Templeton foundation Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer. Warren Stupidity Jun 2013 #28
Prayer is the act of turning toward God kwassa Jun 2013 #30
Just for clarification, it's different from a spell, incantation, or cantrip because it's directed dimbear Jun 2013 #31
What is a "cantrip"? durbin Jun 2013 #32
A cantrip usually means a witch's spell, but it can be any sort of small magic. dimbear Jun 2013 #33
In Britain, it's usually a deceptive move; a sham. rug Jun 2013 #34
Ya think? cbayer Jun 2013 #35
Yup. rug Jun 2013 #36
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»What is prayer?»Reply #5