Democratic Primaries

tonedevil

(3,022 posts)

100. I'm going to award you points for consistency...

Mon Nov 25, 2019, 07:24 PM

Nov 2019

you have not been able to credibly demonstrate that Biden was speaking historically about Moseley Braun so it would be accurate for him to say she was the only African-American Woman elected to the US Senate. You have not been able to offer an explanation as to why if the use of the word only was on purpose and accurate for Biden to say he didn't say that himself in the moment and instead he said he had used the word first. You have not provided any reason to believe that Biden thought of Harris as Indian-American so his overlooking her being an African-American Woman was understandable yet you have brought it up as yet another plausible explanation in the long line of excuses you have proffered.
In the moment Biden revealed what he meant to say and if he had actually said first the first time there would have been no issue. If he had simply said he meant to say first and acknowledged that Booker and Harris were understandably taken aback by the misstatement again no issue. He did get defensive and you have taken that defensiveness to it's deepest darkest conclusion.

If I were to vote in a presidential
primary today, I would vote for: Undecided

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

138 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Maybe Biden thought of Harris as the first Indian-American Senator? [View all] OldRed2450 Nov 2019 OP

Yes. News stories about her Senate win sometimes mentioned ONLY her Indian heritage: highplainsdem Nov 2019 #1

It's nice of you... tonedevil Nov 2019 #2

I'm sure he is aware she is African American OldRed2450 Nov 2019 #3

If you actually think he is aware... tonedevil Nov 2019 #4

This whole thing is petty OldRed2450 Nov 2019 #5

So how does that... tonedevil Nov 2019 #11

No need... pfeiffer Nov 2019 #6

Your argument is wrong and your contempt is petty. If Biden thought of Harris as highplainsdem Nov 2019 #7

When I lived in California PatSeg Nov 2019 #10

I'm pretty sure he meant to say... tonedevil Nov 2019 #13

I didn't understand that either PatSeg Nov 2019 #15

Thank you. I wish I had seen this thread earlier. R B Garr Nov 2019 #23

2nd post- Good catch! Just watched Kamala being sworn in by Biden R B Garr Nov 2019 #25

The OP didn't make the tweet.. why are you being so Cha Nov 2019 #18

She's not African Lizzie Boredom Nov 2019 #26

Not African... tonedevil Nov 2019 #27

Who's "making fun of her DNA"? Lizzie Boredom Nov 2019 #50

Welcome to DU... SidDithers Nov 2019 #45

How did blacks get to Jamaica? Cuthbert Allgood Nov 2019 #73

The OP didn't "manufacture" anything.. as you Cha Nov 2019 #17

Are you suggesting there is any reason... tonedevil Nov 2019 #20

I'm saying you're being rude and insulting. Cha Nov 2019 #21

Sorry. /nt tonedevil Nov 2019 #22

Indian-American Members of Congress Sworn In LongtimeAZDem Nov 2019 #30

I see you! Iggo Nov 2019 #8

I see you too. OldRed2450 Nov 2019 #9

I see you! Cha Nov 2019 #19

that Twitter account is a disgusting troll, it posts and retweets viscous attacks on our Celerity Nov 2019 #12

Joe had an off night. Blue_true Nov 2019 #14

I'm inclined to agree with you PatSeg Nov 2019 #16

That's puting it mildly. InAbLuEsTaTe Nov 2019 #52

Of course you were likely grinning from ear to ear as he stumbled. But it is what it is, Blue_true Nov 2019 #63

Thank you. I wish I had seen this thread earlier. nt R B Garr Nov 2019 #24

He thought of her as a little girl treestar Nov 2019 #28

I live in California... Mike Nelson Nov 2019 #29

Because Joe Biden would never, ever make an incorrect statement. Act_of_Reparation Nov 2019 #31

She identified as Indian-American when he swore her in, so take it up with her LongtimeAZDem Nov 2019 #32

This might come as a huge fucking surprise... Act_of_Reparation Nov 2019 #34

But he had every reason to believe that is how she identified herself, so you have no LongtimeAZDem Nov 2019 #35

He had every reason to believe she identified as Indian. Act_of_Reparation Nov 2019 #36

You are saying the reason... tonedevil Nov 2019 #46

You admitted you could not hear that he said CMB R B Garr Nov 2019 #53

None of that makes sense. tonedevil Nov 2019 #54

You keep trying to change what Biden said so you can push your own agenda with this. R B Garr Nov 2019 #55

Doesn't matter if it was had or has... tonedevil Nov 2019 #56

Look at you dismissing what he actually said to inject your own biased interpretations R B Garr Nov 2019 #57

I have neither added nor subtracted... tonedevil Nov 2019 #58

The video of Biden speaking doesn't match your "transcript". R B Garr Nov 2019 #59

Here's the video since you changed the transcript. 12 seconds in. R B Garr Nov 2019 #60

I don't want you to think... tonedevil Nov 2019 #61

This "conversation" is pretty much your insistence that you want to change Biden's R B Garr Nov 2019 #62

I'm not the one who has two different narratives... tonedevil Nov 2019 #64

You have admitted to refusing to acknowledge R B Garr Nov 2019 #65

I don't know where you see... tonedevil Nov 2019 #68

You refuse to acknowledge what he said. You chamged R B Garr Nov 2019 #69

Read as much or as little... tonedevil Nov 2019 #71

You keep changing Biden's words to fit your gaffe R B Garr Nov 2019 #77

His addition was the opposite... tonedevil Nov 2019 #79

Actually it was Kamala who didn't hear him the first R B Garr Nov 2019 #82

Not quite my take... tonedevil Nov 2019 #85

LOL, now you acknowledge the word he actually said R B Garr Nov 2019 #86

She heard exactly what he said... tonedevil Nov 2019 #87

You've spent 5 days refusing to acknowledge Biden's R B Garr Nov 2019 #89

No... tonedevil Nov 2019 #90

you've spent 5 days denying what Biden actually R B Garr Nov 2019 #91

You think you are the arbitrator of credible? tonedevil Nov 2019 #93

You refused to acknowledge Biden's own words. R B Garr Nov 2019 #94

I think you have made this accusation... tonedevil Nov 2019 #95

You refused to acknowledge what he actually said, which R B Garr Nov 2019 #97

I get it... tonedevil Nov 2019 #98

You refused to acknowledge what Biden said. Your spin R B Garr Nov 2019 #99

I'm going to award you points for consistency... tonedevil Nov 2019 #100

You refused to acknowledge Biden's own words, so your fabrications aren't credible. R B Garr Nov 2019 #101

What he said makes sense... tonedevil Nov 2019 #102

Now you changed his word again. He said "HAD ever been elected" R B Garr Nov 2019 #103

12 seconds in: "who'd ever been elected" Fyi, that means "who had" R B Garr Nov 2019 #104

Now you are changing it to who'd LOL... tonedevil Nov 2019 #105

LOL, it's on the tape, so you can hear it for yourself. It isn't "who has" as you changed R B Garr Nov 2019 #106

Are you saying that he did not say... tonedevil Nov 2019 #107

He described her as the first. It was clear to me. Then he was rudely interrupted. R B Garr Nov 2019 #108

Proof of whose history? tonedevil Nov 2019 #109

You don't need to type his words. You've changed them so many times anyway. R B Garr Nov 2019 #110

If you can't read it I understand... tonedevil Nov 2019 #111

I can read how you changed his words, which is the "it" R B Garr Nov 2019 #112

Whatever... tonedevil Nov 2019 #113

CMB is not a "wild tale", and Biden was talking about her R B Garr Nov 2019 #114

That is the most delusional... tonedevil Nov 2019 #115

LOL, read the thread title. This is not the only thread R B Garr Nov 2019 #116

I read the thread title... tonedevil Nov 2019 #118

You can't even bring yourself to acknowledge Biden's R B Garr Nov 2019 #120

I haven't attributed the thread to you... tonedevil Nov 2019 #121

Keeping up With you changing Biden's words to continue R B Garr Nov 2019 #124

I'm disapointed... tonedevil Nov 2019 #125

6 days, and now you're on a new diversion. At least R B Garr Nov 2019 #126

What are you nattering on about? tonedevil Nov 2019 #127

Thanks for more proof that these so-called Biden gaffes R B Garr Nov 2019 #128

For someone concerned about words being changed... tonedevil Nov 2019 #129

More distraction. But typical of your diversions which R B Garr Nov 2019 #130

It's obvious you've lost and now are diverting into another distraction. R B Garr Nov 2019 #134

LOL, I wasn't talking about when this thread was started, obviously, R B Garr Nov 2019 #138

It's also not a gaffe to remember you swore someone R B Garr Nov 2019 #66

Not only is it not a gaffe... tonedevil Nov 2019 #67

You keep changing Biden's words so you are the one looking R B Garr Nov 2019 #70

Harris Indian-American heritage... tonedevil Nov 2019 #72

You keep changing what Biden said. Over several threads R B Garr Nov 2019 #75

I'm sure anyone correcting you... tonedevil Nov 2019 #80

I have nothing to do with Biden's words. What he said is R B Garr Nov 2019 #83

LOL /nt tonedevil Nov 2019 #88

LOL StarfishSaver Nov 2019 #117

Thanks... tonedevil Nov 2019 #119

What is crazy is to change Biden's words. R B Garr Nov 2019 #136

LOL. I'm just glad that Biden's actual words were finally acknowledged rather R B Garr Nov 2019 #137

That's actually hilarious at this point since you are the one who has been making stuff R B Garr Nov 2019 #135

Post removed Post removed Nov 2019 #132

This is about you changing Biden's words. An opinion doesn't involve R B Garr Nov 2019 #133

I'm actually really worried about him.... Locrian Nov 2019 #84

Because mixed race people have to pick one? IronLionZion Nov 2019 #33

I guess so. Act_of_Reparation Nov 2019 #38

Yes StarfishSaver Nov 2019 #42

Why do people feel the need to excuse what he said? brooklynite Nov 2019 #37

Some candidates' supporters will just keep punching at it, punching at it, punching at it IronLionZion Nov 2019 #39

Aaaawkward progressoid Nov 2019 #92

Super Smooth IronLionZion Nov 2019 #96

Or maybe he just misspoke StarfishSaver Nov 2019 #40

And maybe not; why is it so hard for some of Biden's opponents to cut him some slack? LongtimeAZDem Nov 2019 #41

And you prove my point StarfishSaver Nov 2019 #43

Yeah, sure. Go with that... SidDithers Nov 2019 #44

He'd been encouraged to think of her as a little girl treestar Nov 2019 #47

Who was the third person to walk on the moon? IronLionZion Nov 2019 #48

I find it odd that there's been a few threads about this. Kaleva Nov 2019 #49

I'm with you on this... VarryOn Nov 2019 #76

I don't understand. She's the first Indian American Senator, isn't she? Recursion Nov 2019 #51

Debate video clip IronLionZion Nov 2019 #78

Yikes Recursion Nov 2019 #81

"The only Bla.. African American woman that had ever been elected to the U S Senate" ? Autumn Nov 2019 #122

Biden doesn't make mistakes IronLionZion Nov 2019 #123

This is gross. Just admit he made a mistake. Cuthbert Allgood Nov 2019 #74

Kamala Harris & Mindy Kaling Cook Masala Dosa IronLionZion Nov 2019 #131